7 Instances When Renting Is Better Than Buying

By Kealia Reynolds

Buying a house definitely has its upsides—you’re building equity, you could be paying less in monthly mortgage payments than in rent, and you can modify your house however you like. But if you don’t have a strong enough credit score or are trying to buy a house in an overvalued housing market, renting may be the better option. Here are seven instances when renting is better than buying.

1. You don’t have a strong credit score

A strong credit score is one of the biggest factors considered by lenders in the mortgage application process. To get the lowest interest rate on a mortgage, you’ll need a credit score of 760 or higher. Credit scores below 670 are typically considered subprime and can make it more challenging to get a mortgage, especially one with a competitive interest rate. If you have a lower credit score, you may still be able to get a mortgage, but you’ll likely have to shop around and have more cash on hand for a down payment.

2. You don’t have at least a 10% down payment

For many, especially for first-time home buyers, the biggest obstacle to purchasing a house is saving enough money for a down payment. According to Aaron Galvin, CEO and co-founder of Luxury Living Chicago Realty, “With a mortgage, you need to come up with a 10%–20% down [payment] and jump through hoops to secure lending. With a rental, as long as you have income, a strong credit score, and a clear criminal record, applying for an apartment is easy.”

According to Steven Gottlieb, real estate agent at Warburg Realty, “There are many savvy people in New York City, and if they feel that they can find a better investment than NYC real estate with that down payment money, then I don’t discourage them from making these investments and continuing to rent.”

If you don’t have at least 10% for a down payment, be prepared to pay significantly more in interest over the life of your loan.

Let’s run some quick numbers. Let’s say you want to purchase a $300,000 home. You take out a 30-year mortgage at 4.5%. Here’s what that could look like depending on the size of your down payment.

Down Payment Loan Amount Est. Monthly Payment Interest Paid
5% $285,000 $1,444.05 $234,859.13
10% $270,000 $1368.05 $222,498.12
20% $240,000 $1,216.04 $197,776.11

If you can save enough to put 20% down, you can save more than $37,000 in interest (over the option of 5% down).

Though your monthly mortgage payments may be lower than what you would be paying for rent, buying a house against a mortgage will increase your debt-to-income ratio, which could make it more difficult for you to borrow money for a student loan or car loan. In general, the lower the debt-to-income ratio (it’s recommended that this ratio be 43% to meet the requirements for a qualified mortgage), the better chance you’ll have at securing a loan or line of credit.

3. You don’t have a large enough cash cushion

Before you buy a house, make sure you can afford a mortgage alongside your current expenses and any emergencies that may arise. You should have reserve funds to cover repairs, furnishings, and other fees (like homeowners insurance, property taxes, utilities, etc.), as well as medical emergencies.

“If you own a home or condo, you’re responsible for maintaining the home, and that means [spending] your time and money,” says Galvin. And if you don’t have a home warranty to cover major system breakdowns, you’ll be left paying hundreds—sometimes thousands—of dollars in repairs.

It’s recommended that you have at least three to six months’ worth of living expenses saved up in cash to pay for these expenses.

According to Compass real estate agent Augusto Bittencourt, “There are many additional costs associated with buying a property such as closing costs and home improvements to take into consideration when purchasing. In fact, it’s estimated the average household will spend $14,206 on home improvements during their first two years of ownership.”

If you don’t have extra cash after a down payment and monthly mortgage payments, consider renting for a little while longer.

4. You don’t have enough money to buy what you actually want

If you’re too eager to buy, you may be settling for a house that falls short of personal expectations. Let’s say you prefer to live in a city—the entertainment, walkability, and energy it offers—but the suburbs fall more within your price range at the moment. If you choose to buy a house in the suburbs, you may be sacrificing the urban lifestyle you want. If you wait a few more years and plan carefully, you may be able to afford a home that provides the lifestyle you want.

5. You’re not sure where you’ll be in five years

If you can’t see yourself living in the same place for the near future, then you probably don’t want to invest in a house or condo,” says Galvin. “If you’re renting an apartment and you accept a job offer across the country, you can usually sublet or buy out of your lease with minimal headache. You can move on to the next chapter of your life without becoming a landlord or putting your property up for sale.”

According to Michael Kelczewski, realtor with Brandywine Fine Properties Sotheby’s International Realty, “When you buy a house, the rule of thumb is that you stay in your house for five years or longer to provide the time to recoup your initial investment.” For example, if you own a home for 30 years, the closing costs will likely be offset by an increase in the home’s value. But if you own your house for only two years, there’s a much higher chance that the home’s value won’t have increased, meaning you’ll likely lose money on your investment. So if you’re not sure you’ll be in the same place in the next few years, renting will be much more conducive to your lifestyle.

6. Your housing market is overvalued

An overvalued housing market is one in which homes are priced at least 10% higher than the long-term standard, and local incomes are not expected to support those prices. In an overvalued housing market, it’s likely that buyers will be paying higher-than-normal prices and will have a harder time actually getting the house they want.

According to Nicolas Paredes, real estate agent at Warburg Realty, “With the monthly outlay of common charges and maintenance, the rising interest rates, and the cost of borrowing along with the risk that a property may not appreciate to a number previously expected, some buyers find it is better to rent and wait as they watch property values decrease to more appetizing prices.”

7. You’re shopping in a seller’s market

A seller’s market means that sellers have the upperhand over buyers. This typically means there aren’t enough homes to go around (inventory is low) because there are more buyers than sellers. Due to increased competition, buyers will have to act fast and bid high. The best time to buy a house is, of course, in a buyer’s market—when housing inventory is higher than the number of buyers. You’ll likely be able to buy a great home for a lower cost than you would in a seller’s market.

After considering these reasons, use a rent vs. buy calculator to help you evaluate the cost-effectiveness of each decision.

Looking to save a little money at the same time? A home warranty could protect you against costly home repairs and appliance breakdowns. Check out our in-depth reviews to see which one may be right for you — all of them offer free quotes! 

There's More Where That Came From

Home Warranty

Ask a Pool Expert: How Much Does it Cost to Maintain a Pool?

Pool ownership can be a significant investment of time and money. Read what a pool expert had to say about the reality of at-home pool maintenance and cost.

Home insurance concept. Businessman hold umbrella, modern cottage and paper agreement. Warranty and shield symbol. Protection concept background. Trendy style vector illustration
Home Warranty

Home Warranty Glossary

Browse our glossary of home warranty terms so you can better understand how your policy protects the major appliances and systems throughout your home.

Real estate agent selling a home
Home Warranty

Ask a Real Estate Agent: Are Home Warranties Worth it?

House Method sat down with Brandelyn Jones, a real estate agent with Realty One Group in Goodyear, Arizona, for her expert take on how home warranties can be a valuable asset for homebuyers and sellers. Residing in Arizona since 1997, Brandelyn has specific expertise in the Phoenix Metropolitan market and other neighboring communities. 

Home Warranty

10 Household Items a Home Warranty Covers and 5 It Doesn’t

Home warranties cover normal wear and tear on home systems and appliances. To help you understand repair coverage before purchasing a plan, we’ve compiled a list of 10 household items a home warranty covers and five it doesn’t.

Home Warranty

Ask an Electrician: Are Home Warranties Worth it?

House Method reached out to electrical expert Michael Allred of Allred Electrical Services, Inc. for his professional insight into the true value of home warranty coverage for common household electrical failures. Allred draws from his first-hand experience offering premier electrical services to homeowners in North and South Carolina since 1999.

Home Warranty

How COVID-19 Has Increased the Cost of Homeownership

The COVID-19 pandemic triggered an increase in housing prices and a plummet in available properties. Read this guide to understand the impact of COVID-19 on the U.S. real estate market and how other economic drivers propelled inflation forward since 2020.

Home Warranty

The ROI of a Bathroom Remodel in Every State

House Method ran a survey to find out how much homeowners can expect to get back on bathroom remodeling projects. Explore our survey results and more in this study on the ROI of a bathroom remodel in every state.

Home Warranty

Why Now Is the Time To Invest in a Home Warranty

Now is the time to act if you’ve considered purchasing a home service contract. We’ll explain why you should invest in a home warranty for crucial coverage of your home’s systems and appliances.

Home Warranty

How to File a Home Warranty Claim

There are several steps in the home warranty claims process, some of which can make or break your plan’s success. We’ll show you the four steps to filing a successful claim with your home warranty provider.