Tuft & Needle: Quality Foam Mattress for Less

By David Cusick

Our team writes about products we think you’ll like. We have affiliate partnerships so if you buy any of the products mentioned below, we get a share of the revenue.

Finding the right mattress is a lot of work. With hundreds of options to choose from, it can be overwhelming to even know where to start. You want to make sure you pick the right one because they’re so darn expensive and it’s something you’re going to use every single night. In other words, it better be worth it. But how can you be sure you’re getting the best one? You don’t have time for all that research or hours to spend scrolling through pages of reviews. Lucky for you, at House Method, we do. (We like doing that kind of stuff. Don’t judge us.) That’s right. We’ve gathered up everything you need to know about the Tuft & Needle mattress to help you make the right choice. Here’s what you need to know.

What is the Tuft & Needle Mattress?

The Tuft & Needle mattress is a foam mattress that is made up of two distinct foam layers. This company utilizes a straightforward approach to the construction of their mattress and do not add any frills because they don’t need to. Their mattress stands on its own.

The first layer is called the comfort layer. It’s made of 3” proprietary Tuft & Needle Adaptive® Foam, which consists of a mixture of material that mimics the feel of latex and memory foam. This layer offers pressure relief to sleepers and does not trap heat like a traditional memory foam mattress. It also responds quickly to pressure and has a decent amount of bounce, which makes it easy for restless sleepers to move around during the night without feeling like they’re stuck in a sinkhole.

Beneath the comfort layer is the base, which is a layer of 7” polyfoam. This layer is the foundation of the mattress. It’s much firmer than the comfort layer and offers the most support to sleepers.


Quality Mattress on a Budget

If you’re looking for a deal and want a mattress that’s high quality for the best, most affordable price, you want the Tuft & Needle mattress. While it’s not exactly a luxury mattress, it falls just beneath that line, and still has many of the same features customers crave in a foam bed, just without the fancy frills.

The Tuft & Needle mattress sits in a lower price range without compromising quality. This is accomplished by determining the three most important qualities that are necessary for a top-notch mattress and perfecting those things. To do this, Tuft & Needle focused directly on creating a mattress that offers:

1.) Support
2.) Pressure relief
3.) Cooling technology to prevent overheating

Through trials and testing, they’ve worked to refine their design to make a mattress that is universally comfortable to the average sleeper. This company actually cares about the feedback they receive from customers and have made quite a few changes and upgrades in the past to reflect customers’ preferences, like making the bed softer.


How Does the Tuft & Needle Feel?

In test studies, participants determined the average firmness of the Tuft & Needle mattress to be 7.5 out of 10. This level of firmness comfortably accommodates the average back and stomach sleeper. With this rating, the Tuft & Needle is one of the firmer foam mattresses out there. However, it is still a foam mattress and is not considered very firm. People who have slept on this mattress report good pressure relief for their back, neck, and hips, and enjoy the easy freedom of movement provided by the bounce in the comfort layer.

Like other foam mattresses, the Tuft & Needle performs well in motion transfer tests, showing minimal disturbance. This makes it a perfect mattress for couples because it allows both sleepers the freedom to move during the night, without worrying about waking their partner and getting an earful from them in the morning.

Edge support is the one area that did not perform as well as similar foam mattresses in a higher price range. Users reported that the edges sank low and did not consistently hold a firm shape over time. However, Tuft & Needle listens to customer feedback and is committed to making improvements based on these reviews. Overall, this mattress is the best foam mattress option in this price range.

The Right Mattress For You If:

  • You want a quality mattress on a budget, without all the bells and whistles

Tuft & Needle focuses on mattress quality. If you’re looking for the frills, there are some great options in a slightly higher price range.

  • You want a straightforward mattress that is designed to comfortably accommodate all sleeping styles

The type of sleepers who were most satisfied after sleeping on this mattress was back and stomach sleepers. (Back sleepers, in particular, tend to find this design especially relaxing and supportive because it is on the firmer side for a foam bed.)

  • You want a firmer mattress, but still crave the feeling of sinking into a foam mattress

Many users thought the mattress was soft enough to allow for easy breathing, but firm enough to prevent the hips from sinking too low and putting strain on the lower back.

  • You’re looking for a mattress that allows for easy position changes without causing the bed to shake like an earthquake

The top layer has enough bounce that allows for easy position changes with quick responsiveness.

  • You want a stress-free buying process with a simple and convenient to order and return policy

The bed comes with a 100-night risk-free trial period where your satisfaction is guaranteed. If you end up deciding it’s not the bed for you, no problem. Just send it back.


Not Your Ideal Mattress If:

  • You are a side sleeper

Based on our research and customer testimonials, side sleepers, especially those who are heavier, were not as responsive to this mattress. Some felt that the mattress did not provide enough pressure relief for their shoulders and hips, especially when sleeping curled up. Other side sleepers mentioned that they felt that this mattress was too firm for their liking.

  • You’re looking for a traditional, classic-feeling memory foam mattress

Since it isn’t made with memory foam, but with a similar material, it does not have the slow-sinking feeling of traditional memory foam. It does not have a soft pillow top, so it feels firmer instead of plush.


What are People Saying About Tuft & Needle?

Our friends over at Mattress Advisor gave the Tuft & Needle a solid 9/10, which is an impressive score. The mattress was rated by a strict set of standards, taking into consideration the quality of materials, support and comfort, cooling, edge support, value for money.

Overall, the majority of customers were highly satisfied with their new Tuft & Needle mattress. This is especially true of back and stomach sleepers, with many claiming to see back pain improvements after buying this mattress. One review satisfied sleeper shared, “I have chronic lower back issues and was afraid it might be too soft. That is not the case.”

I have chronic lower back issues and was afraid it might be too soft. That is not the case.”

Through our research, we heard many customers praise the customer service experience they had dealing with this company. Most interactions were quick, convenient and courteous. A common trend we couldn’t help but notice was that many loyal customers felt good supporting such a transparent and reputable company who actually listens to their customers. They felt like their feedback was actually taken into consideration. Others reported being pleasantly surprised by how much they liked sleeping on their Tuft & Needle mattress.

While most reviews shared positive comments about what a good night’s sleep you have on this mattress, other customers shared potential drawbacks. The main concerns we noticed was that the initial reviews of the mattress were stellar but the attitude seemed to shift to a more negative tone after the 7-9 month mark. At this time, some people reporting that the mattress was beginning to lose its firm shape. Some customers shared that their mattress developed grooves and sink spots, while others said that it seemed like the material became softer over time. While the initial sinkage of this mattress was only a few inches, it seems like the sinkage of the material does increase with time and wear.

However, since everyone is different and nothing will ever be one-size-fits-all, we believe your best bet is to try this mattress out for yourself if this sounds like a mattress that suits your needs.


Why We’re Impressed With Tuft & Needle

It’s rare these days to find a company that is as transparent and honest as Tuft & Needle. They truly care about their customers and are dedicated to making improvements and upholding high standards of ethics and values. This online mattress retailer has been around since 2012 and right away they were determined to change the way people bought mattresses. Their goal was to improve the mattress shopping experience by offering mattresses at lower, more transparent cost. That’s right, no hidden fees. Since they ship from the factory directly to you, costs are reduced. This helps the company stand out as being significantly more affordable than their luxury competitors.

One thing about Tuft & Needle that stands out is their dedication to using only the best foam when making their mattresses. If you’re concerned about harmful chemicals in the foam, you can rest easy knowing that Tuft & Needle’s foam is extensively tested and regulated by strict health standards. They have certifications by CertiPUR-US®, GREENGUARD, and OEKO-TEX®, which ensure their mattresses foam passes both the US and global materials test. Each certification has a unique set of standards that carefully check that the foam used in the production is flame retardant, free of heavy metals, made with low emissions to help promote a healthy indoor living space, and free from over 300 harmful chemicals. This mattress is definitely a great option for a safer and healthier nights sleep, free of harmful toxins.

Partnered with Amazon

Tuft & Needle is dedicated to providing its customers with the most convenient and innovative mattress shopping experience on the internet. This seems to have paid off as they are now ranked as the #1 mattress on Amazon. Despite the success they’ve had, they realize that some customers may still be unsure about purchasing “mail order bedding” from some website. So they’ve taken steps to see to it that customers have a stress-free and easy shopping experience. One way they do this is by partnering with Amazon. This comes with the added bonus of free two-hour delivery for Amazon prime members. You can even place mattress orders directly from your phone using the Amazon App. Pretty easy, huh?


Size and Pricing Breakdown:

When you’re ready to purchase your new Tuft & Needle mattress, here are the options you can select from. When comparing the Queen size mattress to competitors, you’ll notice that this option is nearly half as much as a typical Queen, which can easily break $1,000. Overall, Tuft & Needle is a great, affordable foam mattress option.

Pricing Breakdown:

  • Twin – $325
  • Twin XL – $375
  • Full – $475
  • Queen – $575
  • King – $700
  • California King – $700

Our Final Thoughts

Tuft & Needle is a great choice if you’re in the market for an affordable foam mattress. It’s ideal if you’re a back or stomach sleeper who likes a firmer bed. While it does fall at 7.5 on the firmness scale, it is still a foam mattress that you can comfortably sink into. This level of firmness is considered to be comfortable by the majority of average sleepers.

Tuft & Needle is so confident you’ll love their American-made mattress that they’ll even let you try it risk-free for 100 nights. You really can’t beat an offer like that.

On top of that, they offer free shipping to the U.S. and a 10-year non-prorated warranty. What better way for you to see if you like this mattress than to test it out for yourself? Spend a few nights on it and see what you think. After all, if you don’t love it you can always just send it back.

And remember, even though it might not have the bells and whistles of other luxury brand competitors, Tuft & Needle doesn’t waste time on the things that don’t matter. Instead, they place the focus where it should be, on the quality of the mattress.

Transparency to you, our reader, is our top priority.

We believe everyone should be able to make decisions about their home with confidence. While our site doesn’t review every home products or services company in the market, we’re proud that our reviews and recommendations are objective, independent, straightforward — and free.

So how do we make money? Our content is free to you, the reader, because we may earn a commission when you click or make a purchase using our site. This may influence which products we review and write about (and where those products appear on the site), but it in no way affects our recommendations or advice, which are grounded in thousands of hours of independent research. We sometimes offer premium or additional placements on our website and in our marketing materials to our advertising partners but our partners cannot, and do not, pay us to guarantee favorable reviews of their products or services. If you choose to click on the links on our site, we may receive compensation, which then funds our operations.

If you have any specific questions while considering which product or service you may buy, feel free to reach out to us anytime or read our full policy here

By continuing to browse or by clicking “OK” you agree to the storing of first- and third-party cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage, and assist in our marketing efforts. Privacy Policy.