Old Republic Home Protection Review

Data and ratings accurate as of April 2019

By: House Method | Affiliate Disclosure

Old Republic Home Protection is the best home warranty for homeowners in California, as most home warranty companies don’t cover the Western state.

BBB Accredited
After hours service
Covers new construction

There are various home warranty providers and each one offers different plan options. Old Republic Home Protection offers Standard Coverage, Ultimate Protection, Platinum Protection, new construction and multi-unit plans, and optional add-ons. Its pricing varies depending on the size and location of the home, but its plans are affordable.

With over 40 years of experience working in the home warranty industry, Old Republic Home Protection embodies the motto “people helping people,” but are their warranty plans worth buying? How do Old Republic Home Protection plans compare to other home warranty plans? We have aggregated and analyzed Old Republic Home Protection reviews so you can see for yourself. Read on to learn more about the coverage and costs as well as the pros and cons to choosing Old Republic.


Summary of benefits

Average Cost Per Month $32–$62
State Availability 25 states
Service Fee $75–$100
Contract Term 12 months
Time in Business 45 years
Better Business Bureau Rating A+
Review last updated: April 26, 2019


More about Old Republic Home Protection

Years in business

Old Republic Home Protection has been in business for 45 years, which is almost as old as the home warranty industry itself. Its history is certainly a value proposition for customers who appreciate doing business a long-term establishment.

Old Republic Home Protection ratings

Old Republic Home Protection has an A+ rating on the Better Business Bureau (BBB). It has been accredited since November 1, 1996.

Our conclusion

House Method gives Old Republic Home Protection 2.75 out of 5 stars. Some major perks include its various plan options including home warranty coverage for new construction and multi-family units, which we haven’t seen any other home warranty company offer. However, it only covers 25 out of 50 US states.

Old Republic Home Protection reviews

Here are some Old Republic Home Protection reviews from its website:

C.F. from Enterprise, Alabama

Best warranty—worth the price. I originally got one when I purchased my 20-year-old house and I have continued to renew it every year.

C.C. from Tehachapi, California

We purchased an Old Republic Home Protection home warranty for our own home over a year ago. We didn’t need any repairs the first year. However, our dishwasher decided not to work at the beginning of this year.

My husband took care of contacting Old Republic. He said the whole process was very easy, from start to finish. He just had to make one phone call. The repairman called for an appointment, determined the problem, ordered the parts, and came back to install them. That was it, and that was easy. Thank you.

Compare home warranties

Old Republic Home Protection is a good choice for you if …

  • you live in California
  • you own and want to protect a newly built home
  • you manage a multi-family unit

Old Republic Home Protection might not be the right home warranty company for homeowners who live in the Midwest, as it only covers 25 states on the coasts and in the South.

Compare Old Republic Home Protection to the competition.

Home Warranty Company Score Plan Options Monthly Cost Types of Home Covered BBB Rating
Old Republic Home Protection 5.5/10 5 + add-ons $32–$62 Single-family homes, new construction, and multi-family units A+
Choice Home Warranty 10/10 2 + add-ons $29–$42 Single-family units under 5,000 square feet B-
First American 8/10 2 + add-ons $28–$50 Single-family units under 5,000 square feet B+

Frequently asked questions

Does Old Republic cover roof leaks?

Yes, Old Republic covers limited roof leaks. Customers can pay $100 for the optional roof leak repair coverage. Here’s what a sample contract says:

“The repair of specific leaks that occur in the roof located over the occupied living area of the main dwelling (excluding garage), provided the leaks are the result of rain and/or normal wear and deterioration and the roof was watertight and in good condition on the effective date of the Plan.

Not covered: Gutters; drain lines; flashing; skylights; patio covers; scuppers; glass; sheet metal; roof-mounted installations; leaks that occur in a deck or balcony when deck or balcony serves as the roof of the structure below; leaks that result from or that are caused by roof-mounted installations; improper construction or repairs; missing or broken roof shingles or tiles; damage caused by persons walking or standing on the roof; failure to perform normal maintenance to roof and gutters; improper installation; leaks manifested prior to the effective date of the Plan.

Note: An actual water leak must occur during the coverage period for coverage to apply under this Plan. If the area of the roof that is leaking has deteriorated to such an extent that the leak cannot be repaired without partial replacement of the roof, the company’s obligation is limited to the cost of repair if such leak had been repairable. In the event the roof has exceeded its life expectancy and must be replaced, this coverage will not apply.”

Old Republic Home Protection company information

Company name: Old Republic Home Protection
Company type: Public
Ticker symbol: ORI
Founding date: 5/1/1974
Telephone: 800-445-6999
Address: PO Box 5017
State/province: San Ramon, CA
Postal code: 94583
Country: USA

What Did You Think?

Join the Conversation

By continuing to browse or by clicking “OK” you agree to the storing of first- and third-party cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage, and assist in our marketing efforts. Privacy Policy.