Updated November 2018

Best Mattress Toppers

WHY BELIEVE HOUSE METHOD?

We analyze consumer reviews to find the best products on the web. We buy products with our own money and test them in our lab. We also interview experts and conduct independent research to pick the winners. We have affiliate partnerships so we may get a share of revenue from purchases. It’s how we fund our Research Lab and bring you better reviews and comparisons. Read more.

Best Mattress Toppers Updated November 2018

Conclusion

Pros

Cons

Sleep Innovations

4” Dual Layer, Gel Memory Foam
Check Price at: 1 store
When it comes to mattress toppers, 2 layers are better than 1. This machine-washable topper is made out of fiber and gel memory foam.
This double-layered mattress topper retains its shape and supports sleepers who suffer from back pain, making it the best mattress toppers we reviewed
It heats up quickly, so it’s probably a better topper for those who get cold easily.

Memory Foam Solutions

3”, 4-lb. Visco Elastic
Check Price at: 1 store
This memory foam mattress topper is environmentally friendly but may be more delicate than other toppers.
This topper exceeds PURGreen certification standards. It’s temperature-sensitive and reacts to body heat. It feels firmer in cooler temps and softer in warmer.
Have someone give you a hand during the unboxing process because it tends to tear easily.

LUCID

3” Ventilated Memory Foam
Check Price at: 1 store
A 3-inch memory foam topper relieves pressure and joint pain.
Talk about temperature control. This foam is ventilated for a good night’s sleep no matter how warm or cool you sleep.
Some customers say it runs a bit big—it’s a tight fit for fitted sheets.

DreamFoam Bedding

2” Gel Swirl Memory Foam
Check Price at: 1 store
The most affordable memory foam mattress topper we could find.
The 2-inch topper is supportive, comfortable, and not too hot. Customers say it’s just right—a Goldilocks topper if you will.
Foam toppers have a funky smell straight out of the package. Allow them to breathe for a bit before covering them with bedding.

Cloud 9 Bedding Memory Foam

3” Visco Elastic
Check Price at: 1 store
A non-toxic, 3-inch memory foam topper for those who need extra support.
Your comfort’s covered under a 20-year warranty. It’s made right here in the US with non-toxic ingredients.
This topper is thick and may slip or slide off the center, so you may have to reposition it occasionally.

OUR PROCESS

13,510
Customer Reviews
36
Products
12.5
Hours

There’s no one-size-fits-all option when it comes to bedding—especially mattresses. If you’re stuck with a mattress that’s too stiff or too soft, you might be in the market for a mattress topper. We swapped our bedtime reading for mattress topper reviews and shopping guides to help you find the best mattress topper for your sleep situation.

Mattress Topper Reviews Guide

If you’re stuck with an uncomfortable mattress and can’t return it, we found a quick and affordable fix that may make nights a little less restless. Enter the mattress topper: an added layer of cushion and support that lies between you and your mattress. A dense mattress topper can lend more support to a soft mattress or vice versa—a plush topper could make a firm mattress a little softer.

The right mattress topper can relieve some sleep-related aches and pains and can absorb your partner’s movement so you don’t wake up to tossing and turning in the middle of the night. Mattress toppers also extend the life of your mattress.

If you’re ready to invest in an extra layer of comfort, scroll above to our comparison chart of the best mattress toppers. If you still have some questions, our buyer’s guide below can help you navigate the market by answering what type of topper you need and which details to zone in on when reading product descriptions.

 

Types of mattress toppers

Memory foam

Best for: Mattresses that are too soft

  • Pros—This is the most popular type of mattress topper and is available in a variety of density and thickness levels. Most memory foam toppers are also hypoallergenic.
  • Cons—Foam heats up easily, so if you already sleep warm, you might want to consider a different material. New memory foam toppers also release an odor as they expand out of the package, but this should subside within a few days.

Gel

Best for: Warm sleepers

  • Pros—Gel mattress toppers are memory foam’s cool cousin. They have a similar softness and support but provide a cooling effect.
  • Cons—Gel-infused foam toppers have a hefty price tag.

Fiber

Best for: Those on a budget

  • Pros: If you need a quick, budget-friendly fix, fiber mattress toppers are the cheapest.
  • Cons: Fiber isn’t as durable as other types of toppers.

 

Feather

Best for: Mattresses that are too firm

  • Pros—Feather mattress toppers lend that incredibly soft, cloud-like feeling we all crave.
  • Cons—Feather toppers don’t retain their shape, so you’ll have to fluff them often, and they’re not super supportive. Since they’re made with actual bird feathers, they’re not a great choice for allergy sufferers.

Latex

Best for: Allergy sufferers

  • Pros—You’ll get your firm fix with a latex mattress topper. Allergy sufferers and warm sleepers like latex because it’s a breathable material that will resist mold and mites. It’s also a great temperature regulator.
  • Cons—These toppers are top heavy. You’ll likely need help with unpacking and repositioning.

Wool

Best for: Those who sleep through all four seasons

  • Pros—Wool mattress toppers are durable and machine-washable. You shouldn’t experience temperature fluctuations as these toppers stay warm in the winter and cool in the summer.
  • Cons—Wool can be expensive.

Mattress toppers vs. mattress pads

All too often, mattress toppers and mattress pads are marketed as one. Although you could argue that they both protect your mattress, they’re not the same.

A mattress topper fits directly on top of the mattress. It’s thick—sometimes three inches thick—and filled with material like memory foam or down. Toppers add support and cushion to your mattress.

A mattress pad, also called a mattress protector, is secured to a mattress with elastic. The hypoallergenic pad protects it from moisture and normal wear and tear. A mattress pad can actually be used in tandem with a mattress topper.

Best mattress topper for back pain SLEEP INNOVATIONS 4” DUAL LAYER, GEL MEMORY FOAM

This memory foam topper is as supportive as it is soft. We’ve read so many success stories from customers who suffer from back and joint pain. The Sleep Innovations topper is four inches thick and made with two layers: gel memory foam and fiber. This double layer makes the topper retain its shape and remain supportive night after night.

Best memory foam mattress topper MEMORY FOAM SOLUTIONS 3

Smell is a common complaint floating around the memory foam market. Memory foam mattresses often emit a chemical-like odor that can take days to get rid of. This alarms customers and for good reason. Many memory foam products have polyurethane and flameproofing chemicals in them, among other harmful byproducts. Fortunately, there are some clean toppers out there, Memory Foam Solutions 3 being one of them. It’s not only the best memory foam mattress topper, it’s the healthiest as it exceeds PURGreen certification standards.

PURGreen standards include the elimination of ozone-depleting substances and hazardous solvents.”

5 Major factors to consider

Density

Density may be the most important factor to consider when shopping for a new mattress topper. Density refers to how supportive, firm, durable, and heat retentive a mattress topper is. Consider your and your partner’s weight and whether one or both of you tend to sleep warm.

Thickness

The thickness of your topper also matters. Mattress toppers range from one to four inches. Again, a thicker mattress will hold more heat. It’ll also add height to your mattress, so you may have to buy deeper sheets for toppers that are three to four inches in height.

Mattress material

One reason why you might not benefit from a mattress topper is if your mattress was specifically made for your comfort preferences. Even still, a mattress topper can protect and extend the life of your new, custom mattress.

Sleeping habits

Reflect on your sleeping habits before you buy a mattress topper. For example, a soft feather mattress topper is a popular choice for back sleepers, especially if they have a firmer mattress. A thin and firm mattress topper, like one made of latex, is a better choice for stomach sleepers. Side sleepers often need a thicker topper that’s soft and supportive.

Maintenance

Mattress toppers require some maintenance. Give feather toppers a good shake once a week and let other types of toppers air out from under covers every day. Use a mattress pad around your topper to protect it from sweat, stains, and spills. Always refer to the care label before washing your topper. It’s recommended that you wash your mattress topper one to two times per year.

Best mattress topper for temperature control LUCID 3” VENTILATED MEMORY FOAM

If you suffer from night sweats, but your partner is constantly tugging at the blankets, you will both benefit from the LUCID mattress topper. Its ventilated design allows the memory foam to breathe. If you’re wary about memory foam, the open cell technology of this topper prevents any permanent impressions from forming. It’s also resistant to dust mites and allergens, which is great for those who are sensitive to bedding materials.

Best mattress topper warranty CLOUD 9 BEDDING MEMORY FOAM 3

For those that are on the fence about buying a mattress topper, the Cloud 9 is a safe choice for those in-betweeners. It’s three inches of 100% memory foam (the most popular mattress material), it costs less than $100, and it’s covered by a 20-year warranty, which we’ve never seen before. It’s hard to go wrong with this mattress topper.

Natural fibers tend to be cooler and more breathable than synthetic fibers, so if you sleep hot, opt for a natural fiber mattress topper.”

Frequently asked questions

What is the most comfortable mattress topper?

Here’s a checklist for finding the most comfortable mattress topper. It’s soft and supportive like the Sleep Innovation 4-Inch Dual Layer Gel Memory Foam mattress topper. It’s made with non-toxic materials like the Memory Foam Solutions and Cloud 9 Bedding Memory Foam mattress topper. It’s breathable or has a gel design like the LUCID and DreamFoam Bedding topper—this ensures that you and your partner can sleep comfortably through the night.

Which mattress topper is best for back pain?

The Sleep Innovation 4-Inch Dual Layer Gel Memory Foam is the best mattress topper for back pain because it’s equally soft and supportive. Get the best of both worlds from the dual layer that’s made of fiber and gel memory foam. The thickness is also great, as this will help protect your mattress.

What is the best thickness for a mattress topper?

Mattress toppers range in thickness from one to four inches. Stomach sleepers are more keen on thin toppers while side sleepers are more supported by thick toppers. Just remember, mattress toppers add height to your mattress, which makes the fitted sheet all the more challenging. You may have to buy deeper sheets if you invest in a thicker mattress topper.

Does a mattress topper really help?

Yes, a mattress topper does make a difference in support and can make your uncomfortable mattress way more comfortable. It also protects your mattress with an added layer of insulation and reduces movement from nightly tossing and turning.

Can you wash a mattress topper?

You can wash some mattress toppers depending on what material it’s filled with. Check the care label on your topper to determine how to wash it and whether you need to take it to the dry cleaners. You should wash your mattress topper once or twice a year.

The team that worked on this review

Kelsey Roadruck
Writer
Kealia Reynolds
Editor
John Morgan
Producer
Alesandra Woolley
Sleep Expert
Mary Elizabeth Bennett
Sleep Expert
Elizabeth Hennigan
Sleep Expert

By continuing to browse or by clicking “OK” you agree to the storing of first- and third-party cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage, and assist in our marketing efforts. Privacy Policy.

OK