Updated November 2018

Best Comforters

WHY BELIEVE HOUSE METHOD?

We analyze consumer reviews to find the best products on the web. We buy products with our own money and test them in our lab. We also interview experts and conduct independent research to pick the winners. We have affiliate partnerships so we may get a share of revenue from purchases. It’s how we fund our Research Lab and bring you better reviews and comparisons. Read more.

Best Comforters Updated November 2018

Conclusion

Pros

Cons

Royal Hotel

Down w/650 Fill Power
Check Price at: 1 store
This is one of the best comforters on the market. This hypoallergenic comforter is comfortable and warm.
It provides terrific insulation, especially at 650 fill power.
It has also been known to shed feathers.

Pinzon by Amazon

Hypoallergenic White Goose Down
Check Price at: 1 store
The Pinzon by Amazon features 400 thread count with 600 fill power, making it one of the softest and warmest comforters on the market.
The baffles work great and maintain shape and loft (fluffiness). The comforter is machine-washable and dryable. Choose between duck or goose down.
It sheds over time. It doesn't come with a warranty, only a return policy.

Natural Comfort

Soft and Luxurious Down Alternative
Check Price at: 1 store
A hypoallergenic solution to those who are sensitive to goose or duck down.
Though not as fluffy as other comforters, this down alternative is perfect for all-season comfort. It comes with 100% polyester filling and a 300 thread count.
It’s not a lightweight comforter, so you may find it uncomfortable and hot in the summer. It also produces lint after wash and dry cycles.

Chezmoi Collection

White Goose Down Alternative
Check Price at: 1 store
This smooth polyester comforter is one of the more affordable options on the market. It’s comfortable and durable year-round.
It’s 100% hypoallergenic with allergy-free poly fibers. It features a box stitching design to keep fill from shifting.
The comforter may become a bit lumpy after washing.

Superior

All Season Down Alternative
Check Price at: 1 store
Affordably priced, this comforter has an ultra soft shell made of the finest microfibers and lofty down alternative polyfill.
A baffle box construction and double needle stitching prevent fill from shifting. It’s also hypoallergenic, making it a top choice for those allergic to down and feather bedding.
Larger sizes tear during wash cycles. Some customers have complained that this comforter is uncomfortable to use in the summer because it sleeps warm.

OUR PROCESS

12,008
Customer Reviews
53
Products
14.5
Hours

Having a high-quality comforter can make or break your sleeping experience. At House Method, our team is all about getting a good night’s sleep, which is why we tested and reviewed multiple comforters to provide you with information that can guide your purchase. After testing comforters in our Research Lab, we read through thousands of trusted comforter reviews to determine what people value the most—and what irks them—in a comforter. We did the work for you, so you can sleep easier.

Comforter Reviews Guide

A comforter is an essential part of the sleep experience. A good comforter can provide support, comfort, warmth, and a night without any tossing or turning. The wrong comforter can leave you too hot, too cold, too itchy, or just not comfortable at all. With a variety of comforters on the market that contain different fills, stitching, and thread counts, it can be challenging to know which one is best for you and your sleep—that’s where the House Method Reviews team comes in.

If you’re in the market for a new comforter or looking for an upgrade to your current one, you’re in luck. At House Method, we never accept free products from manufacturers and conduct testing and reviews on our own dime. Our reviews are honest and unbiased and we’re here to provide you with the necessary information to make an informed decision when shopping for a comforter. This guide will take you through the most important factors to consider before buying a comforter. We’ll go in-depth with specific product reviews and answer commonly asked questions regarding comforters.

6 Major factors to consider

Shell material

The materials that comprise a comforter’s shell determine its breathability and prevent fill from escaping. Some popular shell materials include cotton, silk, wool, and a cotton/polyester blend.

  • Cotton—This natural fiber has smooth, breathable qualities that deliver a comfortable experience. Cotton is one of the most popular shell materials.
  • Silk—Silk is a natural, hypoallergenic fiber that breathes very well. It has a soft, luxurious feel that can keep you warm and comfortable at night.
  • Wool—Wool retains natural body heat. Therefore, comforters with wool shells are popular in colder climates.
  • Cotton/polyester blend—This type of blend combines synthetic and natural fibers. It’s not as breathable as other shell materials.
Fill material

Like shell material, fill material is another important factor that should be considered when buying a comforter. Two popular fill materials are down and synthetic down.

  • Goose/duck down—Goose down is the most commonly used type of down and is available in white or gray. Note: the color has no effect on the quality or softness of the comforter. White goose down is often used since it doesn’t show through white comforter shells. Down has the advantage of being naturally insulating without being too heavy.
  • Synthetic down—Synthetic down fills are often more affordable than goose down fills and are great for those who suffer from asthma or allergies. Polyester is a popular synthetic fill option because of its affordability and cotton and wool fills are ideal for allergy sufferers.
Best comforter for loft ROYAL HOTEL DOWN W/650 FILL POWER

This Egyptian cotton comforter features a 300 thread count and is filled with natural goose down. The comforter has a high fill power and strong box stitching, preventing the individual pockets of goose down from shifting over time. When you first receive this comforter, you’ll have to manually fluff it for a few days for it to develop a significant amount of loft.

Fill power

Down fill power is a measure of the amount of space one ounce of down takes up. It’s an indicator of warmth and quality. In general, the higher the fill power, the more insulation and better loft. Here are a few fill power ranges and the warmth associated with each one.

  • Lightweight warmth—399 or less
  • All-season warmth—400–599
  • Moderate to high warmth—600–799
  • Highest insulation for winter warmth—800 and up
Size

Measure your mattress before purchasing a comforter. The comforter size should match the size of your mattress. Most comforters are sold for twin, full, queen, and king-sized mattresses. As a general rule of thumb, buy a comforter one size larger than your mattress to eliminate comforter hogging in the middle of the night (this is important if you sleep with a partner). A larger comforter will also hide the sides of your bed if you don’t use a bed skirt.

Matching your comforter weight to the warmth of your environment is one of the most important steps in selecting the right comforter for you. If you live in a warmer climate, a lightweight down comforter is a great option.”

Thread count

If you think thread count only matters for your sheets, think again. Thread count is the number of stitches that bedding has per square inch. A higher thread count means a tighter fabric weave and softer feel. It also comes with a bigger price tag. The key to comforter quality is having a balance between the weave and thread count.

  • 300–500 thread count—Soft, durable comforter at an affordable price
  • 500–800 thread count—Mid-range price with extra durability and comfort
  • 1,000–1,500 thread count—Luxurious comforter with a high-end price tag
Best comforter for allergy sufferers CHEZMOI COLLECTION WHITE GOOSE DOWN ALTERNATIVE

Because the Chezmoi Collection White Goose Down Alternative uses a polyester fiberfill and box stitching, the entire surface area remains at the same level of loft. The polyester fiberfill is also hypoallergenic—a great option for those who are sensitive to goose down or for those who suffer from allergies or asthma.

Stitch construction

The stitch construction prevents fill from shifting. There are several types of stitch constructions to choose from.

  • Baffle box—Strips of fabric called baffles are sewn between the top and bottom layers of the comforter to create compartments for the fill. Baffle walls enable down to expand fully for a high loft.
  • Diamond-quilted—With diamond-quilted construction, the top and bottom layers of the comforter are sewn together in a diamond pattern to eliminate shifting of the fill.
  • Gusset—Walls are created around the edge of a comforter to connect the top and bottom layers. These edges add height to maximize loft. Gusseted comforters typically have baffle-box or sewn-through construction.
  • Karo-step—Cross-stitches create open compartments that allow for some movement of the comfort fill. These comforters can be sewn-through or baffled.
  • Ring-stitch—The top and bottom layers of the comforter are sewn together using small circles, allowing the fill to move around.
  • Sewn-through box stitch—With a sewn-through box stitch, the top and bottom layers of the comforter are sewn together in a box pattern to eliminate the fill from shifting.
  • Sewn-through channel stitch—The top and bottom layers of the comforter are sewn together in horizontal or vertical rows. This construction allows for more movement of the fill than a box stitch.
Best lightweight comforter ROYAL HOTEL DOWN W/650 FILL POWER

Thinner than other comforters, the Royal Hotel Down with 650 fill power provides the coziness and warmth of thicker comforters and quilts. It also provides additional insulation during sleep and is a great option for year-round comfort.

How much does a comforter cost?

Comforters will vary in price based on their size, shell material, fill, and thread count. Inexpensive comforters typically range from $40 to $65, mid-range comforters will cost between $100 and $150, and higher quality comforters can cost $250–$400.

Out of all of the comforters we reviewed, the one that provides the best value is the Chezmoi Collection comforter. This luxury goose down alternative comforter costs less than $35 and features box stitching to avoid shifting of the fill.

If you want a higher quality comforter, we recommend the Royal Hotel comforter. This down comforter provides medium warmth for year-round comfort and has a 300 thread count cotton cover with over 600 filling power. This comforter also has a box stitch design to avoid any fill shifting.

When you bring your new comforter home, it can take up to 72 hours after unpacking for it to expand and achieve maximum loft.”

Caring for your comforter

  • When you first unpack a comforter, it may appear wrinkled or flat. Restore the natural loft by shaking it out for a few minutes. You may have to manually shake out your comforter every so often for a few days after receiving it to achieve maximum loft.
  • Protect your comforter with a duvet cover.
  • Fluff or shake your comforter regularly to expand the down clusters with air and renew their loft.
  • Always check the cleaning instructions for your comforter, as some are dry clean only.
  • Aside from regular spot cleaning, wash your comforter two to three times a year. If you don’t need to take your comforter to a dry cleaner, use warm water and mild detergent on the delicate cycle to clean it. To dry, run the comforter in the dryer on low for a couple of hours.
  • In warmer weather, you may not need a heavy comforter on your bed. Store it in a breathable bag. Stay away from plastic bags—these can cause mildew.
Best low-maintenance comforter CHEZMOI COLLECTION WHITE GOOSE DOWN ALTERNATIVE

The dimensions of this comforter are smaller than average, so you shouldn’t have any problem fitting this product into a large-capacity washer. This comforter also doesn’t require special dry cleaning; most stains can be treated with simple spot cleaning.

Comforter cleaning doesn’t need to occur as frequently as sheet cleaning, but comforters still collect grime and dirt and will require a wash every now and then. Before washing your comforter, note whether it’s better to take your comforter to a dry cleaning service. Some comforters may be too bulky for a washing machine and can become damaged during the washing process.”

Frequently asked questions

What is the best comforter material?

Comforters can be made of a variety of different materials. Some of the most popular are cotton, wool, silk, and bamboo. Cotton is one of the more popular comforter materials as it has wonderful breathable qualities that deliver a comfortable sleep experience. We love the Natural Comfort Soft and Luxurious Down Alternative—it’s a hypoallergenic solution to those who are sensitive to down and is perfect for all-season comfort.

Is down alternative as warm as down?

In general, down comforters tend to be warmer than down alternative of the same weight and size. Down comforters are made of the light, fluffy clusters that come from beneath the feathers of ducks and geese. Down alternative comforters are usually filled with synthetic polyester fills.

What is the highest fill power for a down comforter?

Down fill power is the measure of the amount of space one ounce of down takes up—it’s an indicator of warmth and quality. The highest fill power for a down comforter is 800 and up. You can typically find fill power listed on higher end comforters. The higher the fill power, the better the insulating ability and loft a down comforter will have. The Royal Hotel Down Comforter has a 650 fill power.

Can you wash a down comforter?

You can absolutely wash your down comforter, but be sure to check the wash instructions to determine if it’s better to wash it in your washer or take it to a dry cleaning service. If you’re trying to wash your down comforter at home, use mild detergent, warm water, and wool dryer balls.

What is the difference between a duvet and a comforter?

A duvet is an outer shell that covers a comforter. Its purpose is to protect the comforter and add style—not provide warmth.

The team that worked on this review

Kealia Reynolds
Writer
Rebekah Sedaca
Photo Editor
Kelsey Roadruck
Editor
John Morgan
Producer
Elizabeth Hennigan
Sleep Expert
Alesandra Woolley
Sleep Expert

By continuing to browse or by clicking “OK” you agree to the storing of first- and third-party cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage, and assist in our marketing efforts. Privacy Policy.

OK