Home > Renters Insurance > Best Renters Insurance Companies of December 2023

Best Renters Insurance Companies of December 2023

Updated Jan 12, 2023

Updated Jan 12, 2023

Home > Renters Insurance > Best Renters Insurance Companies of December 2023

We recommend the best products through an independent review process, and advertisers do not influence our picks. We may receive compensation if you visit partners we recommend. Read our advertiser disclosure for more info.

Renters insurance protects tenants and their personal belongings from loss, destruction, or damage caused by unforeseen incidents like fires, water damage, burglary, vandalism, and more.

House Method evaluated more than 50 top-rated renters insurance companies across the United States, hand-picking providers with superior financial strength ratings, affordable premiums, and competitive coverage.

9 Best Renters Insurance Companies of 2023

Here are the nine best renters insurance companies of 2023.

  • Lemonade: Quickest Claims Process
  • Geico: Most Accessible Customer Service Representatives
  • Liberty Mutual: Most Affordable Premiums
  • Amica: Best for Stacked Discounts
  • Nationwide: Best for Coverage Perks
  • Travelers: Best for Customizable Coverage
  • State Farm: Most Comprehensive Personal Property Coverage
  • Allstate: Best for Bundling
  • USAA: Best for Military Members and Veterans

Compare the Best Renters Insurance Providers

We collected averages from each company’s website to provide the following comparison figures:

CompanyAverage Monthly PremiumAverage Annual PremiumAM Best Rating*J.D. Power Score  House Method Rating
Lemonade$12$144Not rated8533.7 out of 5
Geico$14$168A++Not rated4.5 out of 5
Liberty Mutual$14$168A8344.5 out of 5
Amica$13$156A+8494.5 out of 5
Nationwide$14$168A+8594.2 out of 5
Travelers$15$180A++8014 out of 5
State Farm$15$180A++8363.9 out of 5
Allstate$16$192A+8373.6 out of 5
USAA$12$145A++8863.5 out of 5
* AM Best ratings are accurate as of December 2022.
† J.D. Power scores are accurate as of December 2022.

Lemonade: Quickest Claims Process

Quickest Claims Process
  • Easy-to-use mobile app and interface
  • Customizable coverage options
  • Fairly painless claims process

Why We Chose Lemonade Renters Insurance

Lemonade is the superior renters insurance option for tenants seeking quick coverage. We scored Lemonade with 3.7 out of 5 stars, primarily for its prompt claim turnaround times, quality coverage options, and easy-to-navigate online experience. Though the company lost some points for not being accredited by the Better Business Bureau (BBB), we feel confident recommending it.

As the first fully digital renters insurance provider, Lemonade’s artificial intelligence-powered (AI) business model has allowed it to shave down its claims payout time to as little as three seconds.

Pros and Cons of Lemonade Renters Insurance


  • 30% of submitted claims from covered renters are processed and paid out instantly.
  • A portion of the premiums not spent on claims are donated to a non-profit organization of your choice.
  • Offers a 10% discount when policyholders bundle their renters policy with another type of insurance administered by Lemonade, such as life, auto, or pet insurance


  • No live agents to work with—all claims are handled by artificial intelligence, and in-app customer service is limited to chatbots.

Average Annual Cost

Though Lemonade’s most basic renters insurance starts at just $5 per month, your premium will depend on your ZIP code, the level of coverage you select, and whether you opt for any plan add-ons.

We generated a sample renters insurance quote for an alias tenant in Raleigh, N.C. Our sample profile selected a single residency in a local apartment complex with no pets. Based on these specifications, Lemonade quoted our tenant basic coverage for $16.34 per month or $196 per year.

Get a quote: For a free quote from Lemonade, fill out this online form.

Geico: Most Accessible Customer Service Representatives

Most Accessible Customer Service Reps
  • Local insurance partners offer numerous coverage options
  • Discounts for existing auto policy holders
  • Available in all 50 states

Why We Chose Geico Renters Insurance

Renters who prefer live interaction with a real insurance agent will find responsive, solutions-oriented assistance through Geico. House Method scored Geico with 4.5 out of 5 for its broad access to customer care via live chat, phone, email, or mobile app.

It’s worth noting that third-party agencies administer Geico’s renters insurance policies. Tenants who enroll for coverage aren’t through Geico allowed to choose the company they’re matched with. Additionally, Geico policyholders are responsible for filing claims with their third-party provider, which can make getting in touch with the right customer service department a bit more complicated.

Pros and Cons of Geico Renters Insurance


  • Has a 24/7 online virtual assistant for easy policy detail navigation
  • Multi-policy discount available to customers who bundle their Geico renters and auto insurance plans
  • Supports an online calculator feature where you can identify the level of coverage you need based on the value of the belongings in your home


  • Customers don’t have any say regarding the third-party company they’re matched with
  • Renters insurance policies are underwritten and handled by third-party non-affiliated insurance companies, not by Geico

Average Annual Cost

Geico’s website states that its standard renters insurance plans start at $12 monthly. House Method’s research team generated a sample estimate for a tenant residing in a one-bedroom apartment in Raleigh, N.C. We were quoted $28.39 per month or $170.29 per year for basic renters insurance coverage.

Get a quote: For a free quote from Geico, fill out this online form.

Liberty Mutual: Most Affordable

Most Affordable Premiums
Liberty Mutual

Why We Chose Liberty Mutual Renters Insurance

Despite its large industry presence, Liberty Mutual offers some of the most affordable renters insurance rates. In addition to already competitively low pricing, Liberty Mutual offers exclusive discounts for new and long-time policyholders.

Liberty Mutual’s below-average pricing does seem to come at the expense of quality customer service. We discovered low customer ratings for prompt customer service and short wait times when reviewing feedback on verified platforms, including Trustpilot and the BBB.

Pros and Cons of Liberty Mutual Renters Insurance


  • Offers 24/7 customer support
  • Policyholder can choose between replacement cost value (RCV) and actual cash value (ACV) for personal property coverage
  • Supports a mobile app for easy policy management, claims tracking, and quick access to proof of insurance


  • Doesn’t include coverage for losses due to water damage
  • Earthquake coverage is only available in select states

Average Annual Cost

On its website, Liberty Mutual says its premiums for renters insurance start at just $5 per month. We generated a custom quote for a hypothetical tenant living in a one-bedroom apartment in Raleigh, N.C. Selecting only the recommended coverage options, Liberty Mutual quoted us coverage for $14.50 per month or $174 per year.

Get a quote: For a free quote from Liberty Mutual, fill out this online form.

Amica: Best for Stacked Discounts

Best for Stacked Discounts

Why We Chose Amica Renters Insurance

Renters insurance through Amica includes fairly run-of-the-mill coverage items like personal property coverage, personal liability coverage, and loss of use coverage. Amica, however, sets itself apart from other insurers with several specialty discounts for renters, including:

  • Auto-pay discount when you enroll in automatic deductions
  • Claim-free discounts for customers who don’t file claims for three consecutive years
  • E-discount when you sign up to receive bills electronically
  • Loyalty discounts for policyholders of two years or more
  • Up to 15% off when you bundle your renters coverage with car insurance

Pros and Cons of Amica Renters Insurance


  • Includes unlimited personal property protection
  • Offers five discounts accessible to the average tenant without any over-the-top qualifiers
  • Premiums as low as $4 per week


  • Policies must be purchased over the phone and can’t be completed online
  • Not yet available in all 50 states

Average Annual Cost

Amica states its average premium for standard renters insurance costs around $13 per month. We ran a quote for a single tenant occupying a one-bedroom apartment in Raleigh, N.C. Based on these specifications, Amica quoted us coverage for $18 per month or $205 per year.

Get a quote: For a free quote from Amica, fill out this online form.

Nationwide: Best for Coverage Perks

Best for Coverage Perks

Why We Chose Nationwide Renters Insurance

As one of the biggest insurance companies in the United States, Nationwide offers comprehensive renters insurance to an impressive customer base of nearly 9.2 million. Nationwide made our list of top-rated renters insurance companies specifically for its unique coverage items and optional policy riders.

Unlike many competing providers, Nationwide’s standard policies include coverage for stolen credit cards and building alterations. As for add-ons, Nationwide policyholders can add the following to their plan:

  • Earthquake protection
  • Theft extension (covers property stolen from vehicle, watercraft, or trailer)
  • Water backups
  • Valuables Plus (covers jewelry, collectibles, antiques, electronics, etc.)

Pros and Cons of Nationwide Renters Insurance


  • Has a longer list of standard inclusions than competing providers
  • Includes coverage for unauthorized credit card charges, forged checks, and counterfeit cash
  • Supports a number of online tools, like digital calculators for determining things like the value of your personal property or how much coverage is right for you


  • Location may impact the range of coverage options available to you
  • Policies can’t be canceled online, only over the phone

Average Annual Cost

The average cost of renters insurance through Nationwide is $14 per month. For a more personalized point of view, we generated a quote for a single tenant occupying a one-bedroom apartment in Raleigh, N.C. Nationwide calculated a monthly estimate of $19.83 per month or $238 per year.

Get a quote: For a free quote from Nationwide, fill out this online form.

Travelers: Best for Customizable Coverage

Best for Customizable Coverage

Why We Chose Travelers Renters Insurance

With 160 years of industry experience, Travelers is one of the oldest multi-line insurers on the market. Travelers’ expertise in the renters insurance category is reflected in its spread of coverage options and made-to-order policy features.

At sign-up, tenants can personalize their deductible, medical payment, liability, and loss-of-use coverage preferences. Policyholders can also add a la carte riders for replacement cost coverage and protection for big-ticket belongings like jewelry, electronics, collectibles, etc.

Pros and Cons of Travelers Renters Insurance


  • Holds an A++ (Superior) financial strength rating from AM Best
  • Includes limited home improvements coverage to cover repairs for alterations and installation made to the rental property during your tenancy.
  • Offers several one-of-a-kind coverage add-ons like umbrella policies and flood coverage


  • Above-average pricing compared to competing insurers
  • Minimal available discounts

Travelers Renters Insurance Cost

According to its website, standard renters insurance coverage through Travelers costs an average of $15 per month. Travelers quoted a premium of $17.83 per month or $214 per year for a single tenant occupying a one-bedroom apartment in Raleigh, N.C. Travelers offers 15 discounts, some of which include bundling incentives, loss-free discounts, protective device discounts, and a green home discount.

Get a quote: For a free quote from Travelers, fill out this online form.

State Farm: Most Comprehensive Personal Property Coverage

Most Comprehensive Personal Property Coverage
State Farm
  • Offers business and residential renter’s policies
  • Inflation-adjusted coverage provided for personal property
  • Available in 48 states and Washington D.C.

Why We Chose State Farm Renters Insurance

State Farm is our top recommendation for robust personal property coverage for tenants. We scored State Farm 3.9 out of 5, earned specifically for having no annual coverage limits on personal property or loss-of-use claims and for its generous spread of policy add-ons.

When signing up, renters can tack on an endorsement for replacement cost coverage, which covers the entire cost to replace personal belongings lost to an eligible scenario.

Pros and Cons of State Farm Renters Insurance


  • Features a unique identity restoration add-on option, which covers any costs related to reclaiming your identity should you be the victim of online identity theft
  • Includes inflation protection so that your coverage will automatically adjust to rising insurance costs
  • Offers several stackable discounts, including exclusive savings for tenants with smoke detectors, fire alarms, burglar alarms/home security systems, automatic sprinklers, or other dwelling protection features in place


  • Automatic online quotes aren’t always available, depending on your city.
  • Only has three deductible options available.

Average Annual Cost

State Farm advertises renters insurance policies as low as $7 per month. We generated a sample estimate for a renters policy at a one-bedroom apartment in Raleigh, N.C., and were quoted $13.07 per month or $156.84 per year.

Get a quote: For a free quote from State Farm, fill out this online form.

Allstate: Best for Additional Coverage

Best for Bundling

Why We Chose Allstate Renters Insurance

As a household name in the insurance sector, Allstate’s renters insurance stands up to its strong industry reputation. House Method rated Allstate 3.6 out of 5 for its versatile policy options and generous spread of optional coverage add-ons.

Beyond standard inclusions, policyholders can add several extra endorsements to their plan, including coverage for:

  • Extended coverage for jewelry, computers, fur, watches, etc.
  • Identity theft protection
  • Increased coverage for business property
  • Scheduled personal property
  • Uninsured & underinsured motorists

Pros and Cons of Allstate Renters Insurance


  • Offers an extensive list of extra coverage for renters looking to maximize their standard coverage.
  • Personal property coverage is available in either Replacement Cost Value (RCV) or Actual Cash Value (ACV)
  • Policyholders over age 55 will automatically save 25% on their renters insurance premium


  • Policies are administered through third-party insurance companies in select areas.
  • Lower-than-average customer satisfaction scores

Average Annual Cost

A standard renters insurance policy through Allstate starts at just $4 per month. For a more accurate picture of what the average renter might pay, we requested a sample quote for a single tenant occupying a one-bedroom apartment in Raleigh, N.C. Allstate estimated a premium of $12 per month or $143 per year for the Basic policy. Allstate’s Standard plan level would cost $14 per month or $26 for its Enhanced variation.

Get a quote: For a free quote from Allstate, fill out this online form.

USAA: Best for Military Members and Veterans

Best for Military Members and Veterans

Why We Chose USAA Renters Insurance

Exclusively available to active-duty military, veterans, and their immediate family members, USAA is a great option for any tenants occupying military dorms, barracks, or rental property on base.

USAA’s renters insurance includes basic personal property and liability protections plus a few bonus features like flood and earthquake insurance coverage. USAA also throws in up to 28% off for active-duty military members.

Pros and Cons of USAA Renters Insurance


  • Coverage begins for as little as 33 cents per day
  • Coverage extends overseas should you be deployed abroad
  • Military uniforms and apparel are covered for eligible perils with no deductible required


  • Not yet available in all 50 states
  • Only available to members of the military, veterans, and their immediate family

Average Annual Cost

Renters insurance through USAA starts at $10 per month, but premiums are subject to change based on your plan customizations, residence type, and location, among other factors.

For a single tenant residing in a one-bedroom apartment in Raleigh, N.C., USAA estimated a monthly premium of $16.32 per month or $196 per year. Additional discounts include 10% when you bundle with auto, up to 20% when you don’t file any claims for three years, 5% off for homes with protective devices and alarms, and up to 45% for policyholders who reside at a U.S. Military Service Academy.

Get a quote: For a free quote from USAA, fill out this online form.

Video Credit: Allstate

What Does Renters Insurance Cover?

Basic renters insurance is split into three primary types of coverage: personal property, personal liability protection, and additional living expenses/loss of use.

Personal Property Coverage

Personal property coverage includes furniture, clothing, electronics, and other household items and will pay to replace them if they’re even stolen or damaged by a covered risk. Personal property coverage typically doesn’t extend to more valuable items such as jewelry, collectibles, antiques, etc. You’ll need to purchase an additional policy endorsement to secure protection for high-value items like these.

Liability Coverage

Liability protection offers coverage for potential legal fees or medical bills if a guest is injured on the rental property or if you accidentally cause damage to someone else’s property.

Injury and Medical for Guests

Included under standard liability protection is coverage for personal injury to others. Remember that this injury coverage only extends to third parties, whether a delivery person or a guest staying with you. Liability protection will not cover personal injuries to you, the policyholder. If you have roommates listed on the same policy, they also can’t use coverage benefits to cover medical expenses arising from personal injury.

Loss of Use Coverage

Loss of use/additional living expense (ALE) coverage will help offset costs if the property you’re renting becomes uninhabitable due to a covered peril, like a house fire or excessive water damage. This coverage clause will help with hotel fees and other living expenses until you can return to the rental property or relocate.

Who Needs Renters Insurance?

Technically, you only need renters insurance if your landlord, property management company, or complex requires it in your leasing agreement. Renters insurance isn’t legally required in any state.

Still, anyone who rents a home for an extended period, whether an apartment or a single-family house, should consider getting renters insurance as a form of financial protection, even if it is not required by law.

Renters Insurance for College Students

If you’re living off campus, your landlord might require renters insurance in the terms and conditions of your lease. Keep in mind that you won’t be able to take advantage of your roommate’s renters insurance coverage unless your name is listed on it.

If you’re living on campus, you probably won’t need renters insurance for your dorm. Your family’s homeowners insurance policy should often cover all your belongings, including clothes, laptops, and other personal belongings.

Average Cost of Renters Insurance in Every State

In addition to how you customize your coverage, the cost of your renters insurance policy will depend on a handful of identifying details about you, such as your geographic location. Here is an overview of how average premiums vary from state to state:

StateAverage Annual PremiumAverage Monthly Premium
District of Columbia (Washington, D.C.)$158$13
New Hampshire$146$12
New Jersey$156$13
New Mexico$186$16
New York$185$15
North Carolina$159$13
North Dakota$115$10
Rhode Island$182$15
South Carolina$182$15
South Dakota$117$10
West Virginia$185$15
Source: National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) 2019, Average Premiums for Renters Insurance by State via the Insurance Information Institute (III)

The Most Affordable Renters Insurance

If you’re looking for the best cheap renters insurance, here are our top picks:

CompanyLemonadeGeicoState FarmAllstate
Monthly Premium$12$14$15$16
House Method Rating3.7 out of 54.5 out of 53.9 out of 53.6 out of 10
AM Best Score*Not ratedA++A++A+

* AM Best scores are accurate as of December 2022.

How To File a Renters Insurance Claim

To find out what sort of documentation you’ll need to provide to file a claim, visit the website of your renters insurance provider. Any supporting evidence of covered losses, including photos and videos, can be uploaded and submitted through your designated claims portal. More complex claims might require assistance from an agent.

When filing your claim, be as specific as possible about the cause of the loss or damage. If this is your first time filing a claim with your provider, have a copy of your contract on hand, as you’ll likely be asked to provide identifying details like your policy number.

How To Choose the Best Renters Insurance Policy

Choosing the right renters insurance is not as complicated as it looks. Here’s how to get started.

Decide on the Coverage You Want

The amount of coverage you purchase should be enough to cover all your personal belongings in the event of unexpected loss. Some providers, like Geico, offer personal property calculators to help you determine the monetary value of all items within your home. Most standard policy frameworks automatically include personal property coverage, liability coverage, and loss-of-use coverage. Consider any available coverage add-ons if you’re interested in taking your renters insurance policy to the next level.

Cost vs. Cash Value Policies

Property insurance, whether it be renters or homeowners, is typically categorized into two types: Replacement cost value (RCV) or actual cash value (ACV). Replacement cost value describes the cost of replacing an item with a brand-new version at its current retail price. So, if your flatscreen TV is stolen during a break-in, replacement cost value guarantees the latest brand and model of the same TV.

Actual cash value describes the estimated price of the item, considering how much it has depreciated in value over time. For a policyholder with an ACV policy, should their flatscreen TV get stolen, they’ll be compensated for the value of that specific TV.

The key differentiator between these two policy types is that though RCV may pay more in the event of a cover peril, it also costs more in premiums. ACV may not pay as much when you need to file a claim, but it’s the more affordable option monthly.

Compare Companies: Quotes, Reviews, etc.

The best way to weigh your options as you compare different renters insurance options is to generate a handful of quotes with several top-rated providers. Terms and conditions will vary between insurers, so make sure you’re also paying attention to the fine print and not just premiums.

We also recommend skimmer customer feedback from current policyholders on public review platforms like Trustpilot, the BBB, Google Reviews, etc. The best way to predict your future experience with any company is through the eyes of customers who are already enrolled in service. Watch out for review trends regarding unreasonable claim denial, delays in investigation, poor communication, or failed payouts.

Look for Bundles and Discounts

The majority of reputable renters insurance companies offer multiple discounts for new and returning policyholders, often including:

  • Auto-pay discount
  • Claims-free discounts (usually offered after three consecutive years of enrollment)
  • Discounts for senior citizens and members of the military
  • Home safety device discounts
  • Non-smoking discounts
  • Paperless billing discount

Car and Renters Insurance Bundles

Nearly all companies offering renters insurance are multi-line providers. For that reason, they’ll offer a bundling incentive when you opt to purchase property coverage and auto insurance from the same insurer. In addition to securing coverage at a discounted rate, bundling your renters and auto insurance can make policy management easier, with all your coverage details saved in one place.

How To Purchase Renters Insurance

Renters insurance can be easily purchased online through any provider’s main website. If you need additional guidance while navigating different coverage options, you can purchase a policy through a live customer service representative.

Click below to be connected with one of our top renters insurance providers.

Final Thoughts: Best Renters Insurance Companies

More often than not, landlords require tenants to be covered by a renters insurance policy before even signing the lease. Having coverage in place reduces the likelihood of you or your landlord having to cover any damages to the property out-of-pocket. Beyond that, whether renters insurance is worth it is really up to you and your living situation. If you’re renting a property in a neighborhood with high crime rates or strong seasonal weather changes, it’s probably worth the small monthly fee.

Best Renters Insurance FAQs

Does renters insurance cover theft?

Renters insurance does cover theft. Should any personal belongings be stolen from either inside or outside of the rental property, your policy will cover up to your specified personal property coverage limit for the missing items.

What are renters insurance deductibles?

A deductible is a set amount of money you’ll be required to contribute out of pocket toward your first claim before your renters insurance provider will step in to cover the rest. Nearly all insurers give their policyholders several deductible amounts to choose from at sign-up and renewal. The higher the deductible you select, the lower your monthly premiums and vice versa.

What does renters insurance not cover?

Though exclusions vary from one provider to the next, most renters insurance companies will not cover the following:

  • Bed bugs and other pest infestations
  • Damage to your car
  • Extreme weather events (sinkholes, landslides, floods, etc.)
  • Items belonging to a roommate
  • Mold and mildew remediation
  • Personal belongings damaged by you or a pet
  • Undocumented items

Is rental insurance a good idea?

Rental insurance is almost always a good idea, whether your landlord requires it or not. At an average of $15 per month, a standard renters insurance policy can cover you for up to $30,000 in personal property coverage and $100,000 in personal liability coverage.

What are the benefits of renters insurance?

Renters insurance covers your personal belongings from damage or total loss due to covered scenarios such as fire, theft, water damage, etc. Aside from personal property coverage, a standard renters insurance policy also offers liability protection against potential medical and legal expenses should someone become injured while visiting the property. It also covers you for any repair costs that may arise should you ever be at fault for property damage to someone else’s home.

Renters Insurance Ranking and Review Methodology

To ensure that all content published on House Method is rooted in objectivity, editorial integrity, and strategic data collection, we’ve crafted a proprietary composite rating system specifically for our renters insurance category to vet each provider featured across the segment effectively.

Our review standards follow a conventional 10-point scale to measure a company’s insurance product for five overarching criteria points as listed below. From there, those numeric totals are translated into star ratings, partial and whole-star increments, between one and five.

Here are the five major categories that frame our independent review process and their maximum point values:

  • Coverage (3.0): This category evaluates the standard coverage items included in each provider’s policy framework. We looked closely at the breadth of customization options, standout inclusions, cash-out claim types, and more.
  • Monthly Cost (1.5): Our ratings around monthly premiums consider standard policy pricing relative to the current national average ($15 per month). This category also factors in the number, quality, and range of discounts each provider offers.
  • Customer Service (2.0): Scores in the category take into account customer satisfaction and experience based on the following:
    • Consumer feedback published on verified review platforms (Trustpilot, the Better Business Bureau, Google Reviews, etc.)
    • Complaints submitted to state insurance boards as recorded and measured by the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC)
    • Customer satisfaction in the renters insurance segment as indexed by the J.D. Power 2022 U.S. Home Insurance Study.
    • The extent of basic accessibility, as exemplified through customer support business hours, expedited emergency services, ease of claims, convenient quote generation, and bonus digital tools.
  • Endorsements (0.5): This category looks at optional or elective coverage add-ons and riders offered by each featured provider. We gave providers between 0.03 and 0.1 additional points depending on the value of each available add-on.
  • Company Reputation (3.0): Evaluation of each company’s reputation across the renters insurance industry is largely based on ratings issued by the Better Business Bureau, financial strength ratings from AM Best, and NAIC annual complaint indexes.

Other Renters Insurance Resources