6 Best Roofing Materials Ranked
by Durability and Cost

By: Laura Bullard

When choosing a new roof for your home, the most important factors to consider are longevity, cost, durability, energy efficiency, and sustainability of the materials that you choose. All of these elements inform one another.

For example, the durability of your roofing material—or how well it holds up during inclement weather—is ultimately going to affect its longevity. The energy efficiency is going to inform the overall cost—if you choose a cheaper roofing material that is not very energy efficient, your electric bills will be higher.

While material is incredibly important, correct installation can make or break your roof (quite literally). Although DIY projects can be fun and cost-effective, don’t install your own roof unless you’re a trained expert.

It’s also in your best interest to consult an expert before you purchase your material. You will need to consider the slope of your roof, the style of your home, and what roofing material is best for your climate.

These are the six most popular roofing materials (ranked here by longevity and cost). Use this guide to consider the unique advantages of each and choose the right roof for your home.

$ Least expensive
$$$$ Most expensive

1. Asphalt shingles ($)

Asphalt shingles will last for about 15–30 years. They are, far and away, the most popular roofing material because of their cost effectiveness.

When it comes to durability, though, be careful. Never choose the cheapest asphalt shingles, even if cost is a major issue for you. Look for shingles that have a decent hail rating, a good indicator of impact resistance and overall durability.

Roofing material manufacturers are not legally required to report their hail rating, so if you don’t see one, this isn’t a good sign. Hail rating is particularly important with asphalt shingles. Because they’re so common, their quality ranges wildly.

Unfortunately, asphalt is a petroleum-based material. This means that it’s not the most sustainable roofing material option available. Fortunately, asphalt shingles are recyclable—just find a local shingle recycling center and they’ll ensure that your asphalt shingles don’t end up in a landfill.

2. Wooden shingles and shakes ($$)

This roofing material should last between 30 and 50 years. Wood shingles are typically made of fire-resistant woods such as cedar or redwood.

While they last longer than asphalt shingles, they are not as durable. Although they are fire resistant (and can be sprayed with fire retardant), they are not fireproof. Wood shingles and shakes are also prone to cracking, so keep your eye out for a manufacturer with a good hail rating.

When it comes to energy efficiency, wood is a natural insulator—wood shingles are naturally about two times as efficient as asphalt shingles. And because they’re 100% natural, asphalt shingles are one of the most sustainable roofing materials on the market.

3. Metal ($$)

Metal roofing materials will last about 30–50 years. Made of steel, copper, zinc alloy, or aluminum, metal roofs are slightly more expensive than their asphalt and wood counterparts. That said, they are significantly more durable.

Metal roofs are impact resistant and will serve you well in inclement weather (plus, the sound of rain on a metal roof is wonderful). Also, they need a lot less maintenance than most roofing materials. They are very energy efficient—while asphalt shingles tend to hover around the outside temperature (whether high or low), metal roofs act as a natural insulator. This keeps your home cooler during warm weather and warmer during cold weather.

Finally, their recyclability is unparalleled. Not only are most metal roofs created from recycled materials, many are also 100% recyclable themselves.

4. Plastic Polymer ($$$)

Plastic polymer roofs will last for 50+ years and are an incredibly durable roofing material. Polymer roofing shingles are created to look like slate or wood shingles, but they require significantly less maintenance.

Plastic polymer roofs have high hail ratings and they’ll hold up well in inclement weather. Unfortunately, they’re so durable because plastics are built to last, which makes them uniquely unsustainable.

If you decide to use plastic polymer, look for manufacturers that use recycled materials. That said, they are very energy efficient. Plastic roofs, like metal roofs, reflect energy rather than absorb it. This will keep your home cooler during the summer and warmer in the winter.

5. Slate ($$$$)

A roof made from slate can last as long as 75–150 years. One of the oldest roofing materials, slate is also one of the most expensive.

When it comes to durability, slate stands out from the competition. It’s both fireproof and virtually invincible in most inclement weather. Note that installation should be carefully executed—slate tiles can crack under the weight of the average person.

Slate is one of the most expensive materials because it will last for the better part of a century, and if the roof is properly constructed, more than 150 years. Because of this, slate is an incredibly sustainable roofing material.

Roofing waste (specifically asphalt shingle waste) accounts for 3% of all waste in landfills. This is because homeowners have to replace most roofing materials every 30–50 years. A roof that could last three times as long as its competition is much better for the environment.

And slate is a naturally occurring material, which means that the manufacturing process doesn’t introduce toxins. Finally, because slate is one of the densest roofing materials on the market, it’s incredibly energy efficient, helping to regulate your home’s internal temperature.

6. Solar glass ($$$$)

Solar glass roofing should, incredibly, last for the lifetime of your home. Currently, although there are many manufacturers that offer solar panels for your roof, Tesla is the only manufacturer that offers a solar glass roof.

This roofing option comes with a lifetime tile warranty and boasts an extremely high hail rating. The energy efficiency and the cost of solar glass roofing are inextricably linked. Although it’s fairly expensive to install, you may qualify for a tax credit to offset the cost, depending on where you live.

Also, while we calculate the energy efficiency of most roofing materials in terms of how much energy they save, solar glass actually generates its own energy. Because of this fact, solar glass roofing is the most sustainable roofing material on our list.

More on Renovation

Inspiration

Five Ways to Reinvent Your Bathroom in 2019

In 2019, design will be all about classic design meets clean, modern sensibility.

Read More
Maintenance & Renovation

Is Winter Actually the Best Time for a Home Renovation?

Summer may be the most popular time to take on a home renovation, but there are key advantages to cost and availability afforded only in winter.

Read More
Inspiration

A New Fireplace Without a Renovation? That’s a Thing Now

Meet the smokeless, ventless, sootless, odorless, wood-free fireplace that can be added to just about any home.

Read More
Health

What You Didn’t Know About Your Floors: The Surprising Truth Behind Carpets and Hardwoods

Even though hardwoods are thought to be safer and cleaner than carpet, they may not be as safe as you think. We reviewed the health implications of carpets and hardwoods and talked to a few allergy experts about which flooring type is better for your health.

Read More
Maintenance & Renovation

How Much Should You Really Be Budgeting for a Home Renovation?

It’s estimated that nearly half of home renovations go over budget, so how can you plan for the unexpected when it comes to a costly project? We explore how much you should really be budgeting for your reno and how to ensure you stay within budget and on schedule.

Read More
Maintenance & Renovation

Accommodating the Needs of a Multigenerational Household

For multigenerational households that aren’t looking to buy or build a new house, there are changes that can be made to an existing space to make it work for everyone. Here are three ways to accommodate the needs of a multigenerational household.

Read More
Inspiration

Galley Kitchens:
Design Ideas and Configuration Tips

If you’re designing a new galley kitchen or looking to remodel an existing one, we’ll show you how to maximize your space for the most beautiful and efficient layout.

Read More

Subscribe

Get the very best of House Method delivered to your inbox each week


What Did You Think?

Join the Conversation

By continuing to browse or by clicking “OK” you agree to the storing of first- and third-party cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage, and assist in our marketing efforts. Privacy Policy.

OK