Box gutter guards were the most popular type of gutter guards for many years. The K-style gutter guard is now the most common, but there are still many homes with box-style guards still in place. If you are looking for the best gutter guards for box gutters, our guide will help you.
275-micron stainless steel mesh design
Lifetime installation warranty
Offers new gutter installation services
Manufactured to match your home
One-piece system includes a guard and gutter
Guaranteed not to clog
Sturdy aluminum frame and steel screens
Offers 0% financing
Provides gutter repair & installation
Depending on the size of your gutter guard and the overall age and style, your options for gutter guards can be limited. Luckily we have some solutions for custom DIY box gutter guards to help you complete this process and get out of cleaning gutters for good! Let’s look at the top gutter guards available and how you can protect the foundation of your home.
Our Top 9 Gutter Guards For Box Gutters
K Style gutter guards are, without a doubt, the most popular type on the market. However, many of the K-style guards will also work for box gutters. This all depends on the type of box gutters you have, the way they are installed, and the gutter guard you are planning to put in place. At Today’s Homeowner, we have looked at dozens of different gutter providers for box gutter guards. Many of these providers offer custom solutions or larger-dimension gutter guards that can be configured to work for box gutters. We looked at things like pricing, availability of the product, BBB ratings, overall reputation, and more. Here is how the top nine gutter guards for box gutters ranked.
Compare Top Gutter Guard Brands
Company | Logo | Product Image | Our Rating | BBB Rating | Link |
 |  | A+ | |||
 |  | A+ | |||
 |  | B | |||
 |  | A+ | |||
 |  | A+ |
LeafFilter
4.1
Our Rating
LeafFilter Gutter Guards are the best gutter guards on the market. The majority of products offered by LeafFilter are designed to fit with K-style gutters, but this company can make custom solutions for any gutter type. In addition, if your gutter is older and inefficient, LeafFilter can create a custom gutter solution for you with new gutters and gutter guards. With 15 years of experience in the industry, LeafFilter is very capable of creating solutions for a wide variety of gutter issues.
The LeafFilter Gutter Guards are a micro-mesh stainless steel design with impressive functionality, the ability to keep both large and small debris out of the gutter, and a lifetime transferrable warranty. The 275-micron steel mesh will never rust or corrode. In addition, the steel mesh is a good mix of value and functionality. Remember, the hole on a mesh gutter guard still needs to be large enough to accommodate heavy rain. LeafFilter does a great job with this.
- Micro-mesh technology
- Customizable for many gutter sizes and types
- Guards are rustproof
- Professional installation with a lifetime warranty
- A+ rating from BBB
The LeafFilter Gutter Guards have a BBB rating of A+. With 15 years of industry experience, locations in 46 states, and a strong lifetime warranty, you can see why this company moved to the top spot on our list. Trustpilot has collected more than 85,000 reviews of the LeafFilter gutter guards, and the rating is 4.5 out of 5. No other gutter guard providers on our list will have this strong of a reputation in the industry when it comes to both positive reviews and the number of reviews.
Most homeowners find that the quality of the LeafFilter Gutter Guard is nearly impossible to beat. There are some really helpful reviews from customers in areas where rain comes down hard, yet the LeafFilter Gutter Guards are still able to keep up. We are impressed with the lifetime warranty and the way that LeafFilter stands behind it. We saw very few issues with warranties. The only complaint that comes up in the LeafFilter gutter guards reviews deals with the installation process. LeafFilter Gutter Guards are installed by a professional, and you must work with a local installer to schedule your service. Sometimes there are issues with the project taking longer than expected or certain issues with corners and downspouts. Make sure you talk to your LeafFilter representative about the installation process, so your expectations are accurate.
HomeCraft Gutter Protection
4.4
Our Rating
HomeCraft Gutter Protection is the best gutter guard design for box gutters. HomeCraft Gutter Protection guards have won multiple awards for their ability to keep a variety of gutter guard designs free of debris. One of the things that helped HomeCraft Gutter Protection stand out was the raised design on the gutter guard. The raised mesh will help ensure that the debris does not sit directly on top of the box gutter. Even with gutter guard installation, it is important to keep the tops of the gutters clean, and HomeCraft Gutter Protection makes that easier.
Professional installation is required with HomeCraft Gutter Protection gutter installation. With box gutters, the professional installation will help ensure that these heavy-duty guards do the best job they can of keeping leaves, pine needles, and other debris from ending up in the guard.
- Durable 275-micron steel mesh,
- Patented system to help improve water flow
- 304 marine-grade stainless steel
- Lifetime transferable warranty
- Unique design, unlike other gutter covers
HomeCraft Gutter Protection guards are professionally fastened to the roof, not the gutter itself. For some with box gutters, this can help ensure that the gutters prevent debris from sitting on the top of the box gutter. Overall the reviews for HomeCraft Gutter Protection are not as easy to find. This could have to do with the smaller coverage area we see from HomeCraft Gutter Protection. Still, BBB has given HomeCraft a B rating and 4.7 out of 5 stars.
Customers are happy with how these gutter guards keep things like pine needles out of the gutters. In addition, these rain gutters will stop rain damage around the foundation of the home. One of the things that homeowners need to be aware of is the fact that HomeCraft Gutter Protection is typically priced fairly for the features that you will get. The only real complaint we have seen is the inability to work with some larger box gutters, as well as the coloring of HomeCraft Gutter Protection guards looking a little different in person. We suggest ordering color samples to have before you finalize your quote.
LeafGuard
3.5
Our Rating
- Manufactured and installed at your home
- A complete one-piece system with a guard and gutter included
- Limited lifetime warranty
- Guaranteed not to clog
- Oversized downspouts and aluminum that is 20% thicker than competitors
LeafGuard Gutter has 1 out of 5 stars and an A+ rating with the BBB. An A+ rating from the BBB typically means that you can trust the company’s reputation when it comes to warranty and quality issues. The 1 out of 5 stars shows that there are some negative reviews about the gutters and gutter guards from LeafGuard. Trustpilot gives LeafGuard 2.5 stars with a total of 14 reviews. Many homeowners like that LeafGuard has been on the market for so many years and will ensure that your gutter installation is handled with professionalism.
The major negative complaints came from clogging of the gutters. With this being a reverse curve gutter guard, it works a bit differently than a micro-mesh, so you will notice that some smaller debris and things like pine needles sometimes sneak into the gutter. You can periodically clean these in order to ensure proper water pressure, but it comes down to the design of a reverse curve vs. micro-mesh.
All American Gutter Protection
4.1
Our Rating
All American Gutter Protection is the most customizable gutter guard on the market. With All American Gutter Protection, the company will work with you to create a gutter and gutter guard solution that can work for your needs. One thing to remember here is that All American Gutter Protection can also install new gutters if you are looking to replace your current box gutters. The All American Gutter Protection has been in the industry for 6 years, and they continue to grow in size. The service area for All American Gutter Protection continues to grow.
The All American Gutter Protection gutters offer a micro-mesh panel that helps improve the water flow through your gutter guards. In addition, the sides of the All American Gutter Protection guards are made of aluminum material to help decrease the overall weight of the gutters. Perhaps the most impressive thing about All American Gutter Protection is the fact that it is available in more than 30 colors. Whether you have a commercial or residential box gutter, having a choice of colors is essential.
- High-quality stainless steel metal gutters
- Lifetime warranty when professionally installed
- Gutter guards are rust-proof
- Over 30 color options for customers to choose
- Aluminum frame material for longevity
All American Gutter Protection is a fast-growing company and has an A+ rating from the BBB. The BBB rating also shows 4.5 out of 5 stars for All American Gutter Protection. Although there have been some complaints, All American Gutter Protection continually responds to and repairs issues that come up with their gutter guard systems and warranty. The lifetime warranty is a benefit that helped many customers decide All American Gutter Protection was for them.
Overall, people were happy with the performance, stability, and durability of the All American Gutter Protection guards. Having to deal with clogs in the gutters was no longer an issue. The only thing that we noticed as a negative for All American Gutter Protection is the availability of the product across a few different states and the installation. Many homeowners had to wait several days or weeks for their installation, and there were times installers were late or didn’t complete the job. This is just another situation where talking to your sales professional before signing the quote will help to set your expectations about the installation process.
MasterShield
4.5
Our Rating
The MasterShield Gutter Guard is the most environmentally friendly box, gutter guard. The product is made from recycled material that will come with a lifetime warranty. This is a great way to take a waste product and use it for a smart purpose for the rest of its useful life. One of the things that helps the MasterShield Gutter Guard stand out is the angled design. The angled design will prevent debris buildup on the top of the gutter and continue to push the debris down the side of the roof.
If you have had gutter guards in the past, you likely know that they will require you to clean your gutters each season, if not at least twice a year. Having to be on the roof and still do some form of gutter cleaning is a bit troublesome. With the MasterShield guards, a quick brush of the hand or even a landscape blower should give any leftover debris the push it needs to fall off. With this unique design and pitch, you will need a professional to install the MasterShield Gutter Guard.
Castle Windows is the best choice for homeowners seeking comprehensive, long-term warranty protection for their replacement windows. The company provides lifetime guarantees on windows and workmanship, giving customers some of the best buyer protection in the industry.
Castle’s protection applies to window units, glass, and labor, as long as the windows remain in their original openings. Even if you sell your home, its Castle Windows will retain non-prorated protection with transferable lifetime warranty coverage.
Castle provides customers with additional support in its troubleshooting and service guides. The troubleshooting guide provides extensive window maintenance and repair information, and the service guide video tutorials visually demonstrate how to care for your Castle Windows products.
- Pitched design to push debris off
- Lifetime warranty
- Over 14 color options
- Made from recycled materials
- Helps prevent a blockage in the downspout
Overall, MasterShield Gutter Guard is not the largest gutter provider. The smaller providers have fewer individual customer reviews published. However, you should have no trouble finding information from a local installer. The BBB does not accredit the MasterShield Gutter Guard company, but they do give it 3 out of 5 stars. There were some people that had positive experiences with this environmentally friendly guard and found it to be a great solution.
However, the issue that most customers had was the visibility of the guard. Remember that this angled design will stand out a bit more than other options on the market. The angled design may take away from the look you are going for in your home with the box gutters. Many homeowners choose box gutters for the look, and you will have to speak to a MasterShield Gutter Guard representative about whether or not they can match the look of your current home.
Raptor Micro-Mesh Gutter Guard
2.6
Our Rating
The Raptor Gutter Guards are the best DIY mesh gutter guards on the market. These Raptor Gutter Guards are DIY-friendly and are available through purchase through Amazon and not a gutter guard distributor. The Raptor Gutter Guards come with self-tapping screws so that you can install the guards in a matter of minutes to your home. The Raptor Guards come in 5, 6, and 7-inch sizes, which will work for many homeowners with standard-size box gutters.
One of the things that Raptor Gutter Guards claims is that their gutter guards will fit any roof or any gutter type. The micro-mesh gutter guards from Raptor do a really good job of keeping debris out and preventing water damage. The only thing you will need to do is get an accurate measurement of the number of linear feet of gutter guard that you need for your home. Raptor Gutter Guards have a perfect mix of value and functionality, and they come with a 25-year warranty. It is rare to find a DIY product like this with an impressive warranty.
- 25-year warranty
- Rustproof gutter guards with lots of availability
- Three sizes available (5, 6, or 7 inches)
- Stainless steel material
- Any homeowner can install without professional help
The Raptor Gutter Guards are sold on Amazon and can be purchased in any state. The availability of this product is not a concern and is something that can help many homeowners. In addition, there are plenty of reviews on Amazon to help guide you in your decision. We found that out of more than 4000 reviews, the star rating is 4.6 out of 5. This star rating is high and something that should give you quite a bit of confidence in the product you are purchasing.
We assumed there would be negative reviews regarding the overall installation of the Raptor Gutter Guards. However, homeowners were pleasantly surprised by the self-tapping screws and their ease of use. In addition, the overall functionality of the stainless steel micro-mesh also seems to be quite good. One of the complaints we saw was the fact that during a heavy rainstorm, you may see water flow off the edge of the gutter. This can, unfortunately, be a reality with several different types of gutter guards.
Amerimax Home Products
4.0
Our Rating
The Amerimax Lock-In Gutter Guard is the easiest to install gutter guard for box gutters. These lock-in gutter guards should slide under the first row of shingles and then lock into your gutter. This will, of course, have to fit with the recommended sizes that Amerimax Lock-In Gutter Guards are produced in. If you are dealing with a large box gutter guard, a more unique or custom solution will likely be necessary. Amerimax Home Products are fairly priced, come in a few different colors, and make for a relatively easy home improvement project.
If you are new to home improvement projects, the Amerimax Lock-In Gutter Guard will help you feel that you can complete this product on your own. The overall installation is quick, and the powder-coated steel holds up for quite some time. Even though this is a DIY-friendly product, you will still get a 10-year warranty. Overall, Amerimax Lock-In Gutter Guards are something to consider if you have a 4, 5, or 6-inch box gutter. The product is available in a small pack to help you test the fit before making a large purchase.
Castle Windows is the best choice for homeowners seeking comprehensive, long-term warranty protection for their replacement windows. The company provides lifetime guarantees on windows and workmanship, giving customers some of the best buyer protection in the industry.
Castle’s protection applies to window units, glass, and labor, as long as the windows remain in their original openings. Even if you sell your home, its Castle Windows will retain non-prorated protection with transferable lifetime warranty coverage.
Castle provides customers with additional support in its troubleshooting and service guides. The troubleshooting guide provides extensive window maintenance and repair information, and the service guide video tutorials visually demonstrate how to care for your Castle Windows products.
- Made of powder-coated steel
- 4, 5, and 6-inch options
- Available in packs of 1-25
- 10-year warranty
- Rustproof
Amerimax Gutter Guards are sold on Amazon, so the availability to homeowners across the United States is quite good. There are more than 1200 customer reviews from Amerimax, making it one of the more trusted options on the market. With all of these reviews, the product still maintains 4.5 out of 5 stars. The thing that helps the Amerimax Gutter Guards stand out is the ease of installation.
The negative to the Amerimax Gutter Guards is that they won’t snap into place with all box gutters. Your box gutters must accommodate the edge of the Amerimax Gutter Guards, and they must be the 4, 5, or 6-inch box gutters. Some homeowners found that the product didn’t snap in the way it was supposed to. Overall, screen gutter guards are effective, and even if some heavy ratings make it hard for them to catch up at times, for the most part, this is an excellent solution to your gutter guard needs.
GutterStuff Foam Gutter Guards
2.5
Our Rating
GutterStuff Foam Gutter guards are the best foam gutter guards on the market. Depending on the type of box gutter guards you have, foam can be a great solution. The GutterStuff Foam gutter guards should work with a standard 4, 5, or 6-inch box gutter. Large commercial box gutters will need custom foam solutions installed to keep debris out of the gutters. With foam gutter guards, water will soak into the foam, which will transfer it through the gutter; all other debris will be held on top of the gutter guard.
If you are installing GutterStuff Foam Gutter guards yourself, you should not have much trouble with the process. These gutter guards can be cut into the shape that you need, and they come with a 5-year warranty. For those worried about drilling into roof shingles or voiding a roof warranty, the GutterStuff is a perfect solution. In addition, foam gutter guards are typically a more budget-friendly type of gutter guard.
- 15 years of proven performance
- Easy installation
- 5-year warranty
- 4, 5, or 6-inch width options
- 32, 96, 144, or 192-foot length options.
GutterStuff Foam gutter guards are quick to install and fairly priced. The only negative here for box gutters is, again, ensuring that they’ll fit properly. GutterStuff Foam Gutter is available to purchase through Amazon and very easy to work with if they are not the perfect fit. The product has more than 100 reviews on Amazon and a 4.4 out of 5-star rating. Homeowners are quite happy with these gutter guards and their performance, as well as the water flow and large amounts of water the guards can handle.
Foam gutter guards always have one major complaint, and that is the fact that debris will pile up on top of the foam. Most of the time, this can be easily brushed off, but sometimes bristles from branches or pine needles will stick in the foam and make the cleaning process more difficult. Overall, people find foam gutter guards to be a better solution than brush gutter guards, even though they are typically around the same price.
PS Direct Hardware Cloth
2.5
Our Rating
The PS Direct Hardware Cloth is the best box gutter guard for large box gutters. If you have noticed, all of the other solutions on our list of the best box gutters were for 4, 5, 6, or 7-inch gutters. However, there are some box gutters that are large custom solutions spanning between two homes or buildings. It is hard to find a traditional gutter guard manufacturer that will work with a guard this large. However, the PS Direct Hardware Cloth can be an economical and effective choice to consider.
With the PS Direct Hardware Cloth, you get a 1/4-inch hole size that will keep out leaves, unwanted pests, and other large debris. This is a multi-purpose hardware cloth that can be used for several different things as it s made with strong 23 gauge wire. The PS Direct Hardware Cloth is easy to work with and can be conformed to fit a variety of unique box gutter sizes. The product is easy to cut, but you will need to come up with a solution for fastening to the box gutter.
- 1/4 inch opening won’t let large debris through
- Effective at keeping animals out of gutters
- Can easily cut and manipulated for easy installation
- Fair pricing
- Is sometimes the only solution for large box gutters
Customers use the PS Hardware Cloth for a variety of solutions around their homes or farm. The product is affordable, easy to work with, and makes it quick to knock these DIY projects off your list. There are more than 215 ratings for the PS Hardware Cloth, and the average review is still 4.7 out of 5 stars. Of course, this is quite high, but remember that not all customers are using the product as a gutter guard.
When reading through the reviews, we found that those who chose the DIY gutter guard solution found it to be quite effective. The Hardware Cloth is resistant to corrosion and will work very similarly to other mesh gutter guards; it just comes at a lower price. If you have some experience working with these types of projects and need a unique solution, give the PS Hardware Cloth a try.
Buying Guide for Box Gutter Guards
Now that we have given you some of the best box gutter guards on the market, it’s time to break down which one could work for your home or office. The tough part about box gutters is finding the right fit, but many of the gutter guards on our list work for K-style or box-style guards. Here are a few of the things to keep in mind as you are shopping for box gutters.
Quality
The highest quality gutter guards are those with stainless steel micro mesh. The micro-mesh does the best job of keeping debris out of the gutter and ensuring that there is no rusting or corrosion. High-quality gutter guards are worth the money as they typically have longer warranties and options for professional installation.
Cost
The cost of a gutter guard is largely due to its size and the materials used to do the product. Stainless steel micro-mesh guards are entirely different than foam or brush gutter guards. In addition, the size of your home will play into the cost of the gutter guards; large homes will have higher total costs. One of the ways to cut costs on your gutter guard installation is to choose a DIY gutter guard.
Installation
The installation process for most gutter guard manufacturers, like LeafFilter, will take only a day or two to complete. If you want to save money on installation, you can complete the gutter guard installation of something like the Raptor Gutter Guards on your own. DIY gutter guards are cheaper, but you must be comfortable on a ladder and have a friend to help you stay safe during the installation.
Appearance
Most gutter guards are hard to see as they will sit on top of the gutters. However, some gutter guards are installed at an angle, and this makes it difficult for homeowners to find an option that matches their home. The angled design may need to come in a custom color to get it to match your box gutter. The best box gutters on the market will have a design that does not impact the aesthetics of your home.
Size Options
Gutter guards come in a few different sizes, typically 4, 5, and 6 inches. Some guards like the Raptor Gutter Guards also have a 7-inch size to consider. The size of many box gutters will be considerably larger, and this is where you will have to use a custom mesh solution. Make sure to carefully measure not just the width of your gutters but also the number of linear feet that you will need to complete the project.
Warranty
Most of the best gutter guards for box gutters will have some kind of warranty. The cheaper foam-type products typically have a 5-year warranty. Some DIY gutter guards carry a 10-year warranty, and the professionally installed ones typically have a lifetime warranty. The lifetime warranty ensures you will never have to make a gutter guard purchase again. This can be reassuring for many homeowners and something that makes the investment well worth it.
275-micron stainless steel mesh design
Lifetime installation warranty
Offers new gutter installation services
Manufactured to match your home
One-piece system includes a guard and gutter
Guaranteed not to clog
Sturdy aluminum frame and steel screens
Offers 0% financing
Provides gutter repair & installation
Final Thoughts
We hope you now have a better idea as to what you are looking for when it comes to the best box gutter guards on the market. Some homeowners with traditional-size box gutters will have no problem finding a solution. The LeafFilter Gutter Guards are the best overall and will offer an option for brand-new custom gutters if necessary. LeafFilter has more than 15 years of experience and stands out when it comes to quality.
It is important to get more than one quote for your box gutter guards. Making sure that you have looked into all the potential deals and savings is well worth it. Don’t be afraid to negotiate pricing on your box gutters.
Read also: Best Home Depot Gutter Guards (2023)
Frequently Asked Questions
Can you put leaf guards on box gutters?
Leaf guards should work on most box gutters; the main problem that some homeowners run into is the size of the box gutters. Some box gutters are custom solutions to span the gap between two buildings or homes. However, traditional 4, 5, or 6-inch box gutters can handle standard leaf guards quite well.
Is there a gutter guard that works?
The gutter guard that tends to have the best results is the LeafFilter gutter guard. LeafFilter has a stainless steel micro-mesh system that stands out from others on the market. Homeowners find that the LeafFilter gutter guards are durable, long-lasting, and will encourage a lifetime of very minimal gutter cleaning.
Should you put gutter guards on your gutters?
There are several reasons to put gutter guards on your gutters, including:
- Protecting the foundation of your home from water damage
- Keeping leaves and other debris out of your gutter
- Discouraging animals from living in your gutters
- Increasing effectiveness and strength of the current gutter system
- Decreasing the number of gutter cleanings
What is the best gutter guard for box gutters?
The best gutter guard for box gutters is the LeafFilter gutter guard if you want a professional installation. For a DIY installation, the Raptor Gutter Guards will fit on most of the box gutters on the market. Pay close attention to the sizing of the box gutters you have, as this will impact compatibility with certain providers.
Do gutter guards work?
If you choose the right type of gutter guard and have it installed correctly, it should help keep most debris out of your gutters. The best gutter guards on the market are those that have stainless steel mesh, will not corrode, and will ensure that your gutter cleaning responsibilities are significantly reduced.
How We Ranked, Reviewed, and Tested the Best Gutter Guards
Here, we’ve broken down our rating methodology for gutter guards. You should know that we’ve taken the utmost care to provide the most up-to-date information and to ensure that you make the best choice for your budgetary and home maintenance needs.
Why Trust Today's Homeowner? Our Gutter Ranking Methodology
At Today's Homeowner, transparency and trust are our most important values for the reader. We’ve done the homework for you and have researched over 50 gutter guards so you can have the information you need to make the best choice for your home. That’s why we took the time to create an objective rating system and score each gutter guard and gutter guard provider company according to our gutter ranking methodology.
We also dug into the details of each gutter guard to ensure that you could make the best decisions for your home and keep your gutters debris-free for years to come.
To make the most of our research, we developed a formula to objectively determine the best gutter guards based on the following criteria:
- Material: Material durability was the single most important factor that went into our rating methodology for gutter guards. Whether they were stainless steel micro-mesh or plastic screening, we gave an in-depth rating for this criteria.
- Debris Resistance: Our testing served as the primary evaluator for this factor. We curated a rating based on customer testimonials and our own in-house testing here.
- Ease of Installation: Most of the gutter guard options listed have some DIY components involved. For this reason, guards that required the fewest specialty tools got the highest rating here.
- Cost: How reasonable are prices in comparison to the industry average? We compared the costs of each company to competitors.
- Warranty terms: We looked into the warranty of lifetime warranty terms if it is offered by the provider.
- Trust: What do customers rate the company? We looked into what customers are saying about their experience with the company.
- Buying process: if the gutter guard is a DIY installation, how easy is the buying process? We looked for shipping costs and shipping time, as well as where the product can be bought from.
Disclosure: HouseMethod participates in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program. This affiliate advertising program is designed to provide a means for publishers to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
