5 Best DIY Gutter Guards (2021 Review)

By Laura Hodges

Gutter guards are a great addition to any home, but they can be associated with a high cost. One way that homeowners try to save money on gutter guards is by installing the gutter guards themselves. Does this idea appeal to you? In our review of the 5 best DIY gutter guards, we will show you everything you need to know about DIY gutter guards and which are the best to install. You will find out:

  • The top DIY gutter guard brands
  • What to look for when buying gutter guards
  • Our recommendations
  • and much more . . .

Gutter guards are protective covers that are put on the top of your gutters to help eliminate debris. Debris such as shingle dust, leaves, pine cones, and more can completely block your gutters. Using a gutter guard will keep you from having to clean your gutters, and DIY gutter guards come at a great value. Read on to find the best gutter guard for your home.

All gutter guards are available on

Our Top 5 DIY Gutter Guards

There are thousands of DIY gutter guards to choose from. We analyzed each of these gutter guards’ cost, availability, features, effectiveness, durability, warranty, and more. Here is how the top 5 best DIY gutter guards ranked: 

  1. Raptor Gutter Guards:  Best Micro-Mesh DIY Gutter Guards 
  2. LeafTek Gutter Guards: Best Value DIY Gutter Guards
  3. A-M Gutter Guard: Best Warranty 
  4. Amerimax Lock In Gutter Guard: Best Mesh DIY Gutter Guards
  5. Gutter Stuff Foam Gutter Guards: Best Foam DIY Gutter Guards

Compare DIY Gutter Guards

Provider Website/link Cost (200 ft) States Covered Unique features
Raptor Gutter Guards Visit Site $458 All of US Micro-mesh, 25-year warranty, includes self-tapping screws
LeafTek Visit Site  $268 All of US Easy install, 35-year warranty, raised vent ridge 
A-M Gutter Guard  Visit Site  $220 All of US Lifetime warranty, aluminum perforated material, industrial grade 
Amerimax Lock In Gutter Guard Visit Site  $250 All of US Works with several gutter sizes, very easy to install, comes with a Limited ten-year warranty 
Gutter Stuff Foam Gutter Guards Visit Site  $530 All of US Easiest to install, no tools required, trim to cut 

1. Raptor Gutter Guards – Best Micro-Mesh DIY Gutter Guards

Raptor Gutter Guards is leading the way when it comes to the best DIY gutter guards on the market. The great thing about the Raptor Gutter Guards is that they are a micro-mesh option that a homeowner can install without the help of a professional. Micromesh is the leading material in home gutter guards. With micro-mesh, you can block out pine needles, roof grit, leaves, and even animals. 

The Raptor Gutter Guards come in two different size options, one will fit a standard 5-inch gutter, and others will fit the 6 or 7-inch gutter. The way that the Raptor Gutter Guards are installed will not have any impact on your roof warranty. In addition, these gutter guards come with a 25-year warranty. 

As far as warranties are concerned, it is rare to find one this long for a DIY gutter guard product. With corrosion-resistant screws and gutter guard materials that will not rust or warp, the Raptor Gutter Guards are a long-term solution. 

Pros:

Cons:

  • It comes with a 25-year warranty 
  • Two different size options 
  • Micro-mesh material blocks debris
  • Heavy-duty materials 
  • Product provided with self-tapping screws
  • Corrosion-resistant 
  • Easy to install 
  • Higher priced than some other DIY gutter guards 

Key features of this gutter guard: The Raptor Gutter Guards features advanced through technology to pool the water and collect it before falling off the roof. The micro-mesh technology is made from 304 stainless steel to help improve durability and longevity long term. The Raptor Gutter Guards come in two different sizes. 

Who should buy it: Homeowners that have small particles and high levels of roof debris will benefit from the Raptor Gutter Guards. In addition, with the durable stainless steel material, if you have large changes in temperature or wet weather, the Raptor Guard will not rust. 

Go to Amazon to see price and color options.

2. LeafTek Gutter Guards – Best Value DIY Gutter Guards

The best value DIY gutter guards are from LeafTek. LeafTek has managed to put together a high-quality aluminum material gutter guard that comes with a 35-year warranty. The LeafTek gutter guards are made in the United States, and the shipping is quite fast. If you are ready to start working on your gutter guard solution, this could be a great company to consider. 

The LeafTek features a unique vented raised ridge as part of the design. The idea here is that there will be airflow and water flow that will help remove standing water from your gutters. Although you want only water to end up in your gutters, you won’t want the water to just collect in the gutter. 

Installation of the LeafTek gutter guards is relatively easy and will not be installed under the shingles of your home. The roof warranty that you have will be compatible with the installation of LeafTek. Each section that you purchase will come with stainless steel self-tap screws that you can use for quick install. 

Pros:

Cons:

  • Easy to install 4-foot section 
  • It helps to strengthen gutters
  • Stainless steel self tap screws
  • Color-matched screws 
  • Vented design to eliminate standing water
  • 35-year warranty 
  • Large ⅛” holes for better water flow 
  • Fair pricing 
  • Some homeowners will argue that micro-mesh keeps out more debris 

Key features of this gutter guard: The LeafTek gutter guards are one of the easiest and most affordable DIY gutter guards to install on your home. This is perforated aluminum material that allows only small particles and water to pass through. The vented design helps to eliminate problems with standing water and mosquitos. 

Who should buy it: Those that are on a budget yet still want high-quality gutter guards on their homes will find the LeafTek to be a great solution. The LeafTek gutter guards are known to strengthen a gutter and give it a bit more stability. 

To see the current pricing of this gutter guard, look on Amazon.

3. A-M Aluminum Gutter Guard – Best Warranty 

When a gutter guard is not professionally installed, many companies will void any warranty. However, with the A-M Aluminum Gutter Guard, there is so much confidence that you will effectively and efficiently install this gutter guard that it is protected with a lifetime warranty. 

The A-M Aluminum Gutter Guard is designed with a heavy gauge .018 aluminum material. There will never be any rusting on the aluminum gutter guard. In addition, regardless of the amount of debris that collects in or around the A-M Aluminum Gutter Guard, it will never deteriorate. 

If your gutters have tabs in them, these A-M Gutter guards will slide right in and be up within a matter of minutes. You won’t be able to see the product at all when standing on the ground. Make sure to purchase the screws you will need to lock these in place; they are not included. 

Pros:

Cons:

  • Heavy-duty aluminum material
  • No rust or rot
  • Can’t see from the ground 
  • Seamless joints 
  • Can handle downpours
  • Works on metal and shingle roof 
  • Lifetime warranty 
  • It does not come with screws needed to install 
  • Bubble filtration system will allow some water to go over the edge of gutters 

Key features of this gutter guard: The A-M Aluminum Gutter Guards are high-quality aluminum gutter guards with unique bubble perforation to allow only water to pass through. The A-M Gutter guards are never going to rust and will remain in great shape for many years. 

Who should buy it: Homeowners with gutters with hidden hangers will find the A-M Aluminum Gutter guards relatively easy to install. The pricing of these gutter guards is fair, but you must factor in the cost of the screws as well. 

To see sizing, color, and pricing, visit Amazon.

4. Amerimax Lock In Gutter Guard – Best Mesh

The Amerimax Lock In Gutter Guard is easy to install mesh gutter guard. With the Amerimax Lock-In option, your installation process is going to be quite simple and quick. The Amerimax is compatible with a 4, 5, or 6-inch K-style gutter. The mesh pattern is what helps to make sure that the Amerimax is actually effective. 

The “lock-in” part of this process is quite simple. All you will need to do is slide the Amerimax Gutter Guards under the first row of shingles. If this is one of your first DIY projects, you should be able to complete the Amerimax project quite easily. 

The warranty with Amerimax is not quite as long as some other DIY gutter guards on the market. The 10-year limited warranty should be enough to show you the impressive features of this gutter guard, but it is something to consider. 

Pros:

Cons:

  • Made in the USA
  • Durable powder-coated steel 
  • It comes in a neutral color to blend in 
  • Very simple installation process
  • Easy to work in corners and shorter areas 
  • Mesh pattern keeps a good amount of material out of the gutters 
  • Comes with a 10-year limited warranty 
  • About 75 feet of product in each package
  • Not as durable as other gutter guards 
  • Mesh is not as effective as the micro-mesh 

Key features of this gutter guard: The Amerimax Lock In Gutter Guards truly make the DIY project very easy. You will slide this gutter guard into place and then lock it into the gutter itself. Most homeowners find that the durable mesh material will keep the majority of the large debris out, but sometimes smaller particles can pass through. 

Who should buy it: If you have a lot of downpours and you are worried about water flow and debris getting caught up, the Amerimax Lock-In is a good choice. With the larger openings created by the mesh material, lots of water will flow through this gutter guard. 

To see the current pricing of this gutter guard, look on Amazon.

5. Gutter Stuff Foam Gutter Guards – Best Foam DIY Gutters

The Gutter Stuff Foam Gutter guards are the best DIY gutter guards when it comes to ease of installation. When you want to install a gutter guard without tools and heavy-duty equipment, the Gutter STuff Foam Gutter Guards are the best on the market. All you will need to do is cut these gutter guards to the size you need and place them directly in the gutter. 

Unlike traditional mesh or micro mesh gutter guards, the foam gutter guards simply fit right into your gutters. With this gutter guard in place, all of the leaves and debris will collect on top, and the water will run down into the foam. 

The Gutter Stuff Foam Gutter Guards are UV Protectant and will not deteriorate or break down over time. The debris will collect only on top of the gutters, and you can simply blow it off when you need to get debris off the roof. 

Pros:

Cons:

  • 15 years of performance
  • UV Protectant
  • It fits directly in the gutter
  • Easily to clean debris off the top 
  • Simply trim pieces to fit in the gutter
  • Foam will not attract bacteria or water pooling 
  • No tools necessary to install 
  • Fastest installation of DIY gutter guards 
  • Not the best choice in a heavy downpour 
  • Some of the debris can stick in the foam, and you will need to pick it out by hand 

Key features of this gutter guard: The Gutter Stuff Foam gutter guards essentially fill your gutter with foam so that you can allow water to penetrate but keep debris out. The Gutter Stuff guards can be installed within a matter of minutes, and you will notice them working from the time of your first rainstorm. 

Who should buy it: Homeowners that do not experience a wide range of heavy downpours or large amounts of debris will do best with these Gutter Stuff Foam Gutter guards. When water starts running off the roof fast, it is important to use something like a mesh or micro mesh for optimal performance. 

To see current pricing and color options for this gutter guard, visit Amazon.

Buy the top DIY gutter guard

available on Amazon

Buy Now!

What to Look For When Buying DIY Gutter Guards

Quality of the guard

As you can see from our list of the best DIY gutter guards, there are several levels of quality when it comes to gutter guards. Most of the premium guards are made with a stainless steel or aluminum material that is non-destructible. Any part of your home that will be exposed to the elements (both rain and sun) needs to be durable and water-resistant. 

The highest quality guards tend to be the micro-mesh material with stainless steel. These guards seem to last for a very long time and come with an extended warranty. Many gutter guards are made with marine-grade steel accustomed to being exposed to water and rough conditions. 

Price Point

The great news about DIY Gutter guards is that you will save yourself quite a bit of money. Instead of paying for the material and the installation, you should only have to pay for the material. Most DIY gutter guards only require essential tools that should not add to the cost much. 

The best DIY gutter guards are sold by the foot. The guards typically come in three or four-foot sections, and they can be cut where needed to fit around your home. Make sure to take accurate measurements and pay attention to how the size of your home will impact the overall costs of this project. 

Installation

All of the gutter guard choices on our list are DIY friendly and can be installed by homeowners. You should be sure that you are confident on a ladder, and it is a good idea to have a friend help you with this project. 

Some DIY gutter guards come with the self-tapping screws necessary for installation; others will require you to purchase this separately. Overall the tools required to install gutter guards yourself should be limited to a screwdriver, tape measure, scissors or knife, and a hammer. 

Visual appeal

Most gutter guards are designed so that they are not visible from the ground. A gutter guard that is visible from the ground can completely change the look of your home. Ensure that you can also match the color of your gutter guard to the color of your gutters. Most of these are neutral colors that will blend in quite easily. 

Gutter Coverage

Calculating the proper linear footage of your home is an essential part of this process. Before ordering your gutter guards, you will need to do a measurement of your home to see how much material you will need. Many customers have the proper measurement because they were quoted from a full-service gutter company before realizing the pricing was too high. 

We recommend taking one more measurement of your own just to ensure that this number is correct. Take a look at the number of feet included with each pack you are purchasing. This is the only way to be sure that you are getting the gutter coverage that you need. 

Warranty Options

Gutter guards almost always come with warranties when they are professionally installed. However, when it comes to DIY gutter guards, the warranty options are a bit more limited. Truly a company is taking a risk offering a warranty because they can’t monitor your installation job. 

The warranty options for DIY gutter guards range from no warranty to a lifetime warranty. Try to find a product with at least a 15 or 20-year warranty. Most of these warranties are going to project against rusting and corrosion. 

Final Thoughts

We hope you now feel confident about the DIY gutter guards on the market. Taking on the process of installing gutter guards on your own is a tough one; however, it is well worth it. You can save yourself thousands of dollars by installing your own gutter guards. 

All of the companies that we suggested offer great solutions for homeowners. The Raptor Gutter Guards are the best choice because of their impressive micro-mesh technology. If you are serious about a long-term solution, this is a smart gutter guard option to consider. 

It makes sense for homeowners to get several quotes for gutter guards. Being able to compare the quality of a product with the pricing is a great way to decide if this is the best overall gutter guard for your home. Take careful consideration when looking into the installation process to ensure that you have the necessary skills. 

Gutter Guard Company Ranking and Review Methodology

At House Method, transparency and trust are our most important values for the reader. We’ve done the homework for you and have researched over 50 gutter guards so you can have the information you need to make the best choice for your home. That’s why we took the time to create an objective rating system and score each gutter guard and gutter guard provider companies according to our methodology.

We also dug into the details of each gutter guard to ensure that you could make the best decisions for your home and keep your gutters debris-free for years to come.

To make the most of our research, we developed a formula to objectively determine the best gutter guards based on the following criteria:

  • National coverage – If applicable, How many states does the company cover? We found the number of states covered by each company.
  • Customer service: How is the customer experience when calling the providers? Based on our phone calls, we were able to judge each company’s customer service.
  • Trust: What do customers rate the company? We looked into what customers are saying about their experience with the company.
  • Unique perks: Does the company offer discounts or cover special items? We looked for perks offered by each company that sets them apart from the competition.
  • Warranty terms – We looked into the warranty of lifetime warranty terms if it is offered by the provider. 
  • Construction materials – What is the gutter guard made out of? What are the extra parts needed? We found what each company’s guards are made from and how they are installed.
  • Installation process – Does the company do in-person estimates? What are customer experiences when professionals install the gutter guards? We looked into how the installation process works for each provider.
  • Cost – How reasonable are prices in comparison to the industry average? We compared the costs of each company to competitors.
  • Buying process – if the gutter guard is a DIY installation, how easy is the buying process? We looked for shipping costs and shipping time, as well as where the product can be bought from.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why should I install DIY gutter guards?

Installing gutter guards on your own can help to save thousands of dollars. In addition, you will be benefiting from gutter guard technology that keeps you off the ladder and the foundation of your home protected from water collecting and pooling. 

Do I have to get new gutters too? 

Chances are, you will not need new gutters if you are going to install gutter guards. As long as your gutters are in good condition, you should be able to establish a gutter guard on any type of gutter. Always check for compatibility before ordering your new gutter guards. 

Do I need to clean my gutter with gutter guards? 

Even with gutter guards installed, there are times that you will have to clean your gutters. Debris will collect on top of the gutter guards, and you will need to pick it out or blow it off. Cleaning your gutter guards is much simpler than cleaning a gutter that does not have a gutter guard in place. 

Do gutter guards work in heavy rain? 

Gutter guards tend to work in heavy rain as long as the following conditions are met . . .

  • The gutter guard is not covered in debris
  • The holes are big enough to allow fast water flow
  • The sloped angle of the gutter guards is not too severe that it pushes water off the roof 

Do gutter guards go under shingles? 

Gutter guards typically side under the very last layer of shingles. The way the gutter guards slide in, you will not have to worry about lifting the actual shingle or causing any damage to the roof itself. The shingles are easily raised slightly while the gutter guard simply slides underneath. Some non-DIY gutter guards require more movement of the shingle, but almost all DIY options are simple when it comes to the role of shingles. 

More Gutter Guard Resources

Gutters

Best Gutter Guards of 2021

Keep your gutters debris-free! The best gutter of 2021 is Leaf Filter, with runner-ups HomeCraft and All American Gutter Protection.

Exterior of small American house with blue paint and red entrance door. Northwest, USA
Gutters

5 Best Mesh Gutter Guards (2021 Review)

Find the best mesh gutter guards on the market with this guide! Our recommendation: LeafFilter Gutter Guards.

Gutters

5 Best Micro-Mesh Gutter Guards (2021 Review)

Micro-mesh gutter guards keep out even the smallest debris! Find the best micro-mesh gutter guard by reading our guide.

Gutters

LeafFilter Cost (2021)

Looking to get LeafFilter gutter guards installed on your home? Find out if LeafFilter's Gutter Guards and professional installation is worth the cost!

Gutters

5 Best DIY Gutter Guards (2021 Review)

Purchasing DIY gutter guards can save you hundreds. Use our guide to compare the top best DIY Gutter Guards available on Amazon or in your nearby Home Depot.

Gutters

HomeCraft Gutter Protection Review (2021)

Read our HomeCraft Gutter Protection review to learn all about the company's product, cost, warranty, installation, and more!

Gutters

MasterShield Review (2021)

Read our MasterShield review to learn all about the company's product, cost, warranty, installation, and more!

Gutters

All American Gutter Protection Review (2021)

Protect your home from costly water damage with All American Gutter Protection. Use our guide to find out about its product, costs, installation, and more.

Gutters

Gutter Guard Installation Cost (2021)

Total cost of gutter guard installation will likely be between $500 and $2200, depending on materials and house size.

By continuing to browse or by clicking “OK” you agree to the storing of first- and third-party cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage, and assist in our marketing efforts. Privacy Policy.

OK