6 Best Home Warranty Companies
in Stillwater, MN

by House Method Local Advisors - Updated March 9, 2023

A home warranty in Stillwater can help reduce your out-of-pocket costs by covering repairs or replacements to major home systems and appliances that malfunction due to normal wear and tear.

With white winters and beautiful summers, Stillwater is a great place to own a home. However, homeownership doesn't always come easy, like repairing your home's systems and appliances.

Since the home warranty market is filled with a variety of providers — all with different price points — our team at House Method did the research for you to help you find the right home warranty in Stillwater.

Best Overall
  • Over 10 years of experience
  • 24/7 customer service team
  • Home inspections aren’t required
4.8
GET QUOTE
Fast Online Quote
Most Affordable
  • Low service fees compared to other home warranty providers
  • Two months of free coverage
  • Has an appliance-only, systems-only, and combo plan option
4.8
GET QUOTE
Fast Online Quote
Best Customizable Plans
  • The oldest and most trusted company in the industry
  • Allows customers to build their own plans
  • Ability to choose the service fee you want to pay
4.7
GET QUOTE
Fast Online Quote

Choosing a home warranty company in Stillwater


Picking the best home warranty in Stillwater for you comes down to the type of coverage you want, the home warranty provider you go with, and your location, among other factors. Plans can vary, so consider the following factors when picking a home warranty provider:

Quick reference for home warranty companies in Stillwater

$45.00 - $53.33/month
15 years in business
$57.67 - $62.08/month
11 years in business
$29.27 - $74.27/month
26 years in business
$50.40 - $62.90/month
15 years in business
$69.99 - $79.99/month
6 years in business
$34.99 - $67.99/month
44 years in business

Home Warranty Company and Plan Details


There are plenty of companies and policies available to homeowners in Stillwater. House Method took the time and narrowed down the top companies so you can more easily go with the one that has the best policy for your home. Here's how they ranked:
  1. Choice Home Warranty - Best Overall
  2. Select Home Warranty - Most Affordable
  3. American Home Shield - Best Customizable Plans
  4. The Home Service Club - Quickest Service
  5. Liberty Home Guard - Most Trustworthy
  6. Cinch Home Services - Best Workmanship Guarantee

Choice Home Warranty

4.85

Best Overall

Choice Home Warranty logo
MONTHLY COST $45.00 - $53.33
YEARS IN BUSINESS 15

Over 10 years of experience

24/7 customer service team

Home inspections aren’t required

90-day repair guarantee

Plans aren’t customizable

Customers can’t choose their own contractor

Not available in Washington

In Stillwater, Choice Home Warranty is the best overall home warranty. If you're looking for very high coverage caps and simple-to-understand service contracts, Choice is the perfect provider for you. Plus, it has great customer service, professional contractors, and lower out-of-pocket costs compared to other home warranties. Choice has 2 simple plans, making the selection process and policy coverage easily comprehensible.

Choice Home Warranty offers 2 plans for Stillwater homeowners. The Basic Plan and Total Plan are the options they have, which have a mix of system and appliance coverage. Choice has coverage caps of around $3,000 for most appliances and systems, but with some plans, the coverage caps can be higher, so make sure to check with the provider. Service fees are an affordable $85.

To get a free quote from Choice Home Warranty, fill out this online form or give them a call at 929-400-6164. For a more detailed breakdown, read our thorough review of Choice Home Warranty.

Home Warranty Plans from Choice Home Warranty

Basic Plan
Service fee: $85.00 Monthly cost: $45.00 Items covered: Ceiling fan, Cooktop exhaust, Dishwasher, Disposal, Ductwork, Electrical, Garage door opener, Heating system, Oven, Microwave, Plumbing system, Toilet, Water heater Add-on items: Pool, Spa, Septic, Well pump, Roof leaking, Septic tank, Sump pump, Vacuum, Stand-alone freezer
Total Plan
Service fee: $85.00 Monthly cost: $53.33 Items covered: Ceiling fan, Cooktop exhaust, Dishwasher, Disposal, Ductwork, Electrical, Garage door opener, Heating system, Oven, Microwave, Plumbing system, Toilet, Water heater, AC, Washer, Dryer, Refrigerator Add-on items: Pool, Spa, Septic, Well pump, Roof leaking, Septic tank, Sump pump, Vacuum, Stand-alone freezer

Select Home Warranty

4.8

Most Affordable

Select Home Warranty logo
MONTHLY COST $57.67 - $62.08
YEARS IN BUSINESS 11

Low service fees compared to other home warranty providers

Two months of free coverage

Has an appliance-only, systems-only, and combo plan option

90-day repair guarantee

Has a $75 cancellation fee

Low coverage caps

Select Home Warranty offers the most cost-effective home warranty for Stillwater residents. If you're looking for a highly affordable service fee and free roof coverage upon purchase of a policy plan, you'll want to have this plan on your side. Plus, it has an extensive network of highly trained professionals all over the country who are experts in home maintenance. The 3 policies that Select offers include differing levels of system and appliance coverage, as well as add-on options.

Select Home Warranty offers 3 plans for Stillwater homeowners. The Bronze Care Plan, Gold Care Plan, and Platinum Care Plan are the options they have, which have a mix of system and appliance coverage. The coverage caps from Select are about $2,000. The service fees are a reasonable $60, which is lower than other providers in the Stillwater area.

To receive a free quote from Select Home Warranty, fill out this online form or call 888-370-3953. To read more, visit our Select Home Warranty full review.

Home Warranty Plans from Select Home Warranty

Bronze Care Plan
Service fee: $60.00 Monthly cost: $57.67 Items covered: Disposal, Dishwasher, Dryer, Microwave, Oven, Refrigerator, Washer Add-on items: Pool, Spa, Septic, Sprinkler, Stand-alone freezer, Vacuum, Well pump, Sump pump, Roof leaks
Gold Care Plan
Service fee: $60.00 Monthly cost: $57.67 Items covered: Air Conditioner, Ductwork, Electrical, Heating system, Plumbing, Water heater Add-on items: Pool, Spa, Septic, Sprinkler, Stand-alone freezer, Vacuum, Well pump, Sump pump, Roof leaks
Platinum Care Plan
Service fee: $60.00 Monthly cost: $62.08 Items covered: Disposal, Dishwasher, Dryer, Microwave, Oven, Refrigerator, Washer, Air conditioner, Ductwork, Electrical, Heating system, Plumbing, Water heater, Ceiling fan, Garage door, Plumbing stoppages Add-on items: Pool, Spa, Septic, Sprinkler, Stand-alone freezer, Vacuum, Well pump, Sump pump, Roof leaks

American Home Shield

4.75

Best Customizable Plans

American Home Shield logo
MONTHLY COST $29.27 - $74.27
YEARS IN BUSINESS 26

The oldest and most trusted company in the industry

Allows customers to build their own plans

Ability to choose the service fee you want to pay

Broad coverage on up to 33 appliances and systems

Doesn’t let customers choose their own technician

Doesn’t provide coverage in Alaska

In Stillwater, American Home Shield offers the most customizable home warranty. The home warranty company offers 3 plans to policyholders that have various options for appliance and system coverage. If you're looking for the ability to customize your plan with the coverages that work specifically for your home, you'll want to have this plan on your side. Plus, it has a remarkably low claim denial rate in comparison to other home warranty companies.

The plans that AHS offers to homeowners are ShieldSilver, ShieldGold, and ShieldPlatinum. The coverage caps associated with AHS's plans are around the $2,500 mark for most of the major systems and appliances, and service fees are customizable and range from $75 to $125.

To read more, visit our full review of American Home Shield. To receive a free quote from American Home Shield, fill out this online form or give them a call at 888-365-2839.

Home Warranty Plans from American Home Shield

ShieldSilver
Service fee: $75.00 - $125.00 Monthly cost: $29.27 - $44.27 Items covered: Air Conditioner, Alarm, Attic fans, Bath exhaust fans, Ceiling fans, Cooktop exhaust, Disposal, Doorbell, Ductwork, Electrical, Garage door, Heating system, Locksmith, Plumbing, Plumbing stoppages, Toilet, Water dispenser, Water heater, Whole house fan Add-on items: Pool, Spa, PC, TV, Septic, Well pump
ShieldGold
Service fee: $75.00 - $125.00 Monthly cost: $39.27 - $54.27 Items covered: Air conditioner, Alarm, Attic fans, Bath exhaust fans, Ceiling fans, Cooktop exhaust, Dishwasher, Doorbell, Dryer, Ductwork, Electrical, Garage door, Heating system, Microwave, Oven, Plumbing, Plumbing stoppages, Refrigerator, Toilet, Trash compactor, Washer, Water heater, Whole house fan Add-on items: Pool, Spa, PC, TV, Septic, Well pump
ShieldPlatinum
Service fee: $75.00 - $125.00 Monthly cost: $59.27 - $74.27 Items covered: Air conditioner, Alarm, Attic fans, Bath exhaust fans, Ceiling fans, Cooktop exhaust, Dishwasher, Disposal, Doorbell, Dryer, Ductwork, Electrical, Garage door, Heating system, Locksmith, Microwave, Oven, Plumbing, Plumbing stoppages, Refrigerator, Roof leaks, Toilet, Trash compactor, Washer, Water dispenser, Water heater, Whole house fan Add-on items: Pool, Spa, PC, TV, Septic, Well pump

The Home Service Club

4.7

Quickest Service

The Home Service Club logo
MONTHLY COST $50.40 - $62.90
YEARS IN BUSINESS 15

Policy starts in ten days

24/7 customer service support

Generous coverage caps on important systems and appliances

30-labor guarantee and 90-day parts guarantee

Offers utility and home service outside line coverage

Higher service fee of $95

Not accredited by the Better Business Bureau (BBB)

Only 2 plan options

The Home Service Club is the best home warranty with the quickest service in Stillwater. The home warranty company offers 2 plans to policyholders, which have various system and appliance coverage options. With a home warranty from HSC, you can enjoy quick coverage where the home warranty goes into effect just ten days after you pay for the plan, instead of the typical 30 days. Not to mention, it has customer service representatives available 24/7, as well as a 30-day labor guarantee and a 90-day parts guarantee.

There are 2 home warranty plans from The Home Service Club: Standard Coverage Plan and Comprehensive Coverage Plan. HSC's service fees are customizable and range from $65 to $90, and the coverage limits come out to around $2,000 for each covered system or appliance.

To get a free quote from The Home Service Club, fill out this online form or call 800-750-9443. For more information on this provider, read our comprehensive review of The Home Service Club.

Home Warranty Plans from The Home Service Club

Standard Coverage Plan
Service fee: $60.00 - $95.00 Monthly cost: $50.40 Items covered: Air conditioner, Ceiling fan, Dishwasher, Garbage disposal, Dryer, Electrical system, Food center, Free-standing ice maker, Garage door opener, Heating system, Microwave, Oven, Plumbing, Refrigerator, Trash compactor, Central vacuum, Washer, Water heater Add-on items: Utilities and home service line coverage (outside gas line, outside water line, outside sewer line, sprinkler system, Pool, Spa, Water softener, Roof leaks, Well pump, Pump, Stand-alone freezer
Comprehensive Coverage Plan
Service fee: $60.00 - $95.00 Monthly cost: $62.90 Items covered: Air conditioner, Alarm wiring, Attic fans, Ceiling fan, Dishwasher, Garbage disposal, Doorbell, Dryer, Ductwork, Electrical system, Food center, Free-standing ice maker, Garage door opener, Heating system, Microwave, Oven, Pest control, Phone, Plumbing, Plumbing stoppages, Refrigerator, Sump pump, Toilet, Trash compactor, Central vacuum, Washer, Water dispenser, Water heater, Whole house fan Add-on items: Utilities and home service line coverage (outside gas line, outside water line, outside sewer line, sprinkler system, Pool, Spa, Water softener, Roof leaks, Well pump, Pump, Stand-alone freezer

Liberty Home Guard

4.65

Most Trustworthy

Liberty Home Guard logo
MONTHLY COST $69.99 - $79.99
YEARS IN BUSINESS 6

Very highly rated among customer service reviews

Covers repairs with a 60-day workmanship guarantee

Extensive list of 20+ add-on coverages

Easy claims process

Isn’t available in 2 states

Won’t cover known or unknown pre-existing conditions

Liberty Home Guard offers the most trustworthy home warranty in Stillwater. The 3 plans from Liberty are easily comprehensible and offer both system and appliance coverage. With a home warranty from Liberty, you can enjoy a seamless complaint process and guaranteed service professionalism upon every repair visit. Not to mention, it has a 60-day workmanship guarantee and some of the best customer service in the industry.

There are 3 home warranty plans from Liberty Home Guard: Appliance Guard, Systems Guard, and Total Home Guard. The coverage limits from Liberty are around $3,000. The service fees are an affordable $75, which is less than other providers in the Stillwater area.

To get a free quote from Liberty Home Guard, you can fill out this online form or call 866-451-2281. To read more, visit our review of Liberty Home Guard.

Home Warranty Plans from Liberty Home Guard

Appliance Guard
Service fee: $75.00 Monthly cost: $69.99 Items covered: Ceiling Fan, Cooktop exhaust fan, Disposal, Dishwasher, Dryer, Garage door, Microwave, Oven, Refrigerator, Refrigerator ice maker, Washer Add-on items: Pool, Saltwater pool, Spa, TV, PC, Pump, Generator, Free-standing ice maker, Septic tank pumping, Roof leaks, Pests, Water softener, Well pump, Wine refrigerator, Septic, Sprinkler, Locksmith, Trash compactor, Sump pump, Vacuum, Stand-alone freezer, Water dispenser
Systems Guard
Service fee: $75.00 Monthly cost: $74.99 Items covered: Air Conditioner, Bath exhaust fan, Ductwork, Electrical, Heating system, Plumbing, Plumbing stoppages, Toilet, Water heater Add-on items: Pool, Saltwater pool, Spa, TV, PC, Pump, Generator, Free-standing ice maker, Septic tank pumping, Roof leaks, Pests, Water softener, Well pump, Wine refrigerator, Septic, Sprinkler, Locksmith, Trash compactor, Sump pump, Vacuum, Stand-alone freezer, Water dispenser
Total Home Guard
Service fee: $75.00 Monthly cost: $79.99 Items covered: Ceiling Fan, Cooktop exhaust fan, Disposal, Dishwasher, Dryer, Garage door, Microwave, Oven, Refrigerator, Refrigerator ice maker, Washer, Air Conditioner, Bath exhaust fan, Ductwork, Electrical, Heating system, Plumbing, Plumbing stoppages, Toilet, Water heater Add-on items: Pool, Saltwater pool, Spa, TV, PC, Pump, Generator, Free-standing ice maker, Septic tank pumping, Roof leaks, Pests, Water softener, Well pump, Wine refrigerator, Septic, Sprinkler, Locksmith, Trash compactor, Sump pump, Vacuum, Stand-alone freezer, Water dispenser

Cinch Home Services

4.35

Best Workmanship Guarantee

Cinch Home Services logo
MONTHLY COST $34.99 - $67.99
YEARS IN BUSINESS 44

Offers home insurance deductible of $500

Extra long 180-day workmanship guarantee

Offers free cancellation in the first 30 days

Charges high service fees of $75-$150

Doesn’t allow customers to choose their own technician

Isn’t available in Hawaii or Alaska

In Stillwater, Cinch Home Services is the home warranty with the best workmanship guarantee. Cinch has been in the home warranty business for about 43 years. Cinch offers a 180-day workmanship guarantee that ensures your home systems and appliance repairs will be professionally done. Plus, it also has a broad range of coverage options that will give homeowners peace of mind. Cinch offers 3 plans for you to choose from.

Cinch Home Services has 3 plans that offer a combination of system and appliance coverage. Cinch's service fees are customizable and range from $75 to $150, and the coverage caps come out to around $1,000-$2,000 for each covered appliance or system.

To get a free quote from Cinch Home Services, fill out this online form or give them a call at 877-589-0505. Read our Cinch Home Services Review to learn more.

Home Warranty Plans from Cinch Home Services

Appliances Plan
Service fee: $75.00 - $150.00 Monthly cost: $34.99 - $50.99 Items covered: Cooktop exhaust fan, Dishwasher, Dryer, Food center, Free-standing ice maker, Microwave, Oven, Refrigerator, Refrigerator ice maker, Trash compactor, Washer Add-on items: Pool, Septic, Well pump
Built-in Systems Plan
Service fee: $75.00 - $150.00 Monthly cost: $39.99 - $57.99 Items covered: Air conditioner, Smoke alarm, Attic fans, Bath exhaust fans, Ceiling fans, Disposal, Doorbell, Ductwork, Electrical, Garage door, Heating system, Plumbing, Plumbing stoppages, Septic tank pumping, Spa, Sump pump, Toilet, Vacuum, Water dispenser, Water heater, Whole house fan Add-on items: Pool, Septic, Well pump
Complete Home Plan
Service fee: $75.00 - $150.00 Monthly cost: $49.99 - $67.99 Items covered: Air conditioner, Alarm, Attic fans, Bath exhaust fans, Ceiling fans, Cooktop exhaust, Dishwasher, Disposal, Doorbell, Dryer, Ductwork, Electrical, Food center, Free-standing ice maker, Garage door, Heating system, Microwave, Oven, Plumbing, Plumbing stoppages, Refrigerator, Refrigerator ice maker, Septic tank pumping, Spa, Sump pump, Toilet, Trash compactor, Vacuum, Washer, Water dispenser, Water heater, Whole house fan Add-on items: Pool, Septic, Well pump

Additional home warranty information


Cost to replace or repair common home appliances and repair damages in Stillwater

AIR CONDITIONER
$6,396
HEATING
$4,264
ELECTRICAL
$640
TOILETS
$533
WASHER/DRYER
$853
PLUMBING
$640
OVEN/STOVE
$1,706
FRIDGE
$640

Many home warranties cover or have options to cover appliances and other expensive repairs, which can save you significant money over time.

Looking to save big when things go wrong?

Get a free quote from our #1 recommended provider in Stillwater

GET QUOTE


What is a home warranty?

A home warranty is a service contract that covers the cost of repairing or replacing major home systems and appliances when they break over time due to normal wear and tear. Having a home warranty in place can offer you some peace of mind and guard your savings account from exorbitant out-of-pocket costs. Most home warranty plans take effect about 30 days after buying the home warranty.

When a covered appliance or system needs to be repaired, you file a claim with your home warranty company. Most companies have an online portal system to help you do this. Once you file the claim, it will be assigned to a local technician or repair person who will come and assess the issue. At this point, you will pay a service fee, which is generally between $60 and $150 depending on what plan you have. After the service fee is paid, a repair person will come to your home, assess the issue, and make the repair. If the repair is covered by the warranty and the coverage cap is not reached, most homeowners will not have to pay any other out-of-pocket costs after the service fee is paid.

What does a home warranty cover?

A home warranty plan will cover systems and appliances that have stopped working due to normal wear and tear. For instance, if your refrigerator suddenly stops working under normal use conditions, this is a perfect time to call your home warranty provider. Appliances covered under a home warranty plan are typically the dryer, garbage disposal, refrigerator, dishwasher, microwave, and more. Systems that are covered usually include heating systems, electrical systems, water heaters, plumbing systems, and air conditioners. Add-on options can vary by company but often include things like a septic system, sprinkler system, central vacuum, second refrigerator, and plumbing stoppages.

A home warranty will only cover normal wear and tear that occurs on your home systems and appliances. Things like misuse, lack of maintenance, pre-existing conditions, and cosmetic damages are not included in the home warranty policy.

Is a home warranty worth it in Stillwater?


Benefits of a home warranty

Since temperatures in Stillwater can hit the negatives in the winter, the extreme weather can put a lot of strain on your heating system. Buying a home warranty plan can help homeowners save money if one of these systems or appliances breaks unexpectedly.

Additionally, having a home warranty can save you time by getting rid of the need to research service technicians--most providers will send a trusted professional right to your door to carry out the necessary repair or replacement.

Downsides of a home warranty

Home warranties also have some downsides. Though it can save you time when the home warranty sends out a service technician who handles the repair for you, some people may not like this, and they may want to select their own contractor. If that's the case for you, some home warranty plans allow you to select a contractor. Another consideration is that home warranties usually only cover repairs needed due to normal wear and tear. They most likely won't cover home systems or appliances that have need repairs or replacements due to natural disasters, animal infestations, improper maintenance, etc.

Although home warranties do have some downsides, whether during winter, summer, or the months in between, a home warranty can help reduce the inevitable cost of home appliances and system repairs, giving you a little peace of mind.

Final Thoughts

A home warranty can save you a decent amount of money on home maintenance and offer you peace of mind as a homeowner in Stillwater. The best provider in Stillwater is Choice Home Warranty. It offers great coverage of all the essential home appliances and systems at an affordable cost with several add-on options.

Best Overall
  • Over 10 years of experience
  • 24/7 customer service team
  • Home inspections aren’t required
4.8
GET QUOTE
Fast Online Quote
Most Affordable
  • Low service fees compared to other home warranty providers
  • Two months of free coverage
  • Has an appliance-only, systems-only, and combo plan option
4.8
GET QUOTE
Fast Online Quote
Best Customizable Plans
  • The oldest and most trusted company in the industry
  • Allows customers to build their own plans
  • Ability to choose the service fee you want to pay
4.7
GET QUOTE
Fast Online Quote

Home Warranty FAQs


Which home warranty company is the best?

The top home warranty company in Stillwater is Choice Home Warranty. Choice Home Warranty has an expansive network of professional repair technicians and a great reputation in the Stillwater area.

What's a home warranty?

A home warranty is a of service contract designed to give homeowners extra coverage for their household systems and appliances. These include dishwashers, washing machines, garbage disposals, dryers, refrigerators, plumbing, electrical systems, heating and cooling systems, water heaters, and sump pumps, among others. Some companies also offer coverage for garage door openers, pools, ceiling fans, and roofs. A home warranty can help you save money if these appliances and systems break down unexpectedly.

What's the difference between a home warranty and homeowners insurance?

Home warranty plans cover problems related to home systems and appliances that need repairs or replacements due to normal wear and tear. A homeowner's insurance policy is a different insurance that protects the entire home from natural disasters and fires. It doesn't cover normal appliance or system repairs.

Who should get a home warranty?

A home warranty policy can help investors, homeowners, homebuyers, real estate agents, and home sellers. It can offer peace of mind and savings to anyone that is involved with homeownership.

What is a service fee?

The service fee is the price you pay every time there's a problem with a system or appliance. The service fees are typically priced between $60 and $150.

How much does a home warranty cost in Stillwater?

A Stillwater home warranty can cost between $40 and $80 a month. Higher-priced plans usually have more coverage, higher coverage limits, and a lower service fee.

Other Stillwater Home Services

More Home Warranty Companies Near Me Guides