Home > Home Warranty > Top 6 Best Home Warranty Companies for First-Time Home Buyers (2023)

Top 6 Best Home Warranty Companies for First-Time Home Buyers (2023)

Updated Jan 31, 2023

Updated Jan 31, 2023

Home > Home Warranty > Top 6 Best Home Warranty Companies for First-Time Home Buyers (2023)

We recommend the best products through an independent review process, and advertisers do not influence our picks. We may receive compensation if you visit partners we recommend. Read our advertiser disclosure for more info.

Buying your first home is an incredibly exciting experience involving lots of paper signing and transferring hard-earned money. Although there are so many positive benefits of living in a home, there are negatives that first-time buyers often overlook.

Nobody likes to think of it, but what happens when your heating system or microwave decides to stop working just a few weeks after you purchased your home. This is where finding one of the best home warranties for first-time buyers comes into play.

Our Top 6 Home Warranty Companies for First-Time Home Buyers

First-time home buyers should take comfort in knowing that all six of our top home warranty companies are credible, professional, and well established across the United States. We compared pricing structures, coverage options, service fees, BBB ratings, cancellation fees, coverage caps, and more.

Here are the top 6 home warranty companies for first-time home buyers.

  1. Best Overall: Choice Home Warranty
  2. Most Customizable: American Home Shield
  3. Most Cost-Effective: Select Home Warranty
  4. Most Trustworthy: Liberty Home Guard
  5. Best Appliance Coverage: First American Home Warranty 
  6. Best for Immediate Service: ServicePlus Home Warranty

Why Trust House Method

  • 63 companies reviewed
  • 41 key factors analyzed
  • 2,583 data points parsed
  • 885 homeowners surveyed
  • 57 service contracts scrutinized

House Method’s Experts collected and analyzed 2000+ critical data points to identify what makes a great home warranty company in the eye of the consumer. Our reviews team used this data to assess over 60 home warranty providers for coverage extent, annual cost, and national availability to provide unbiased reviews so homeowners can confidently navigate key decisions about their homes.

Compare Home Warranty Providers

ProviderMonthly CostService FeeBBB RatingStates Covered
Choice Home Warranty Basic Plan: $45/monthTotal Plan: $53.33/month$85B-47 states, not including CA, NV
American Home Shield ShieldSilver: $34.99-$49.99/monthShieldGold: $44.99-$59.99/monthShieldPlatinum: $59.99-$74.99/month$75-$125B49 states (Not including AK)
Select Home Warranty Bronze: 36/monthGold: $36/monthPlatinum: $38/month$75B46 states(Not including NV, NY, WA, WI)
Liberty Home GuardAppliance Guard: $64.99/monthSystems Guard: $69.99/monthTotal Home Guard: $74.99/month$75A+48 states (Not including WA and WI)
First American Home WarrantyBasic Plan: $38/monthPremier Plan: $48.50/month$85B33 states (not including AL, CT, DE, HI, IL, LA, ME, MA, MN, NH, NJ, NY, ND, RI, VT, WI)
ServicePlus Home Warranty Gold Plan: $53.67/monthPlatinum Plan: $60.33/month$75NR46 states (not including CA, NY, NV, WA)

1. Choice Home Warranty

Best Overall
Choice Home Warranty
  • 2 plans available + optional add-ons
  • Has over 11 years of industry experience
  • 90-day repair guarantee
  • $46–$55 per month with $85 service fee

Choice Home Warranty is the best overall home warranty for first-time home buyers. Purchasing a home can be very confusing. There are a number of different plans, policies, and agreements that you will be responsible for. Therefore a complicated home warranty service contract will turn many first-time home buyers away from the home warranty. Luckily Choice Home Warranty has one of the most straightforward service contracts in the world of home warranties. With 13 years in the industry, Choice Home Warranty knows exactly what first-time home buyers need.

 In addition to the clear and concise service contract,  Choice Home Warranty also keeps its plans simple and straightforward. There are two Choice Home Warranty plans to choose from, and they are both comprehensive coverage options. First-time home buyers will not need to decide between covering appliances or systems,  as both are covered under the Choice Home Warranty.

Pros & Cons


  • Straightforward service contract 
  • 90-day workmanship guarantee
  • Fair pricing for combo plan
  • Plenty of add on options
  • More than 13 years in the industry


  • No ability to build a custom plan 

Plans and Pricing

PlanPrice Per MonthPrice Per Year
Basic Plan $45$560
Total Plan$53.33$660


One of the major considerations for first-time homebuyers looking into home warranties is the policy’s coverage caps or limits.  Some home warranty companies have a coverage cap or limit of around $500.  However, with Choice Home Warranty, the coverage caps are more than $2,500. This means if your first home has high-end appliances and systems, The Choice Home Warranty is well-equipped to cover any issues that could come up.

The Choice Home Warranty is one of the most trusted home warranty policies in the US. Customers enjoy how easy it is to work with Choice Home Warranty and the overall affordability of the plan.

To get a free quote from Choice Home Warranty, fill out this online form or call 929-400-6164.  

For more information, read our Choice Home Warranty Review.

2. American Home Shield

Most Customizable
American Home Shield
  • 3 plans + add-ons and the option to build your own plan
  • Customers can choose the service fee they want to pay
  • Provides generous coverage caps
  • $35–$75 per month

American Home Shield  is a premium home warranty company for first-time home buyers. The American Home Shield Home Warranty has been on the market for more than 50 years. This makes AHS one of the leaders in the home warranty industry.  First-time home buyers looking for premium coverage, customization, and impressive customer service will find American Home Shield to be a great match. 

With the American Home Shield Home Warranty, you can build out a home warranty policy to match the needs of your home. If you have an extra refrigerator,  no microwave,  or simply don’t want coverage for your water heater,  American Home Shield makes building a plan relatively simple. 

Pros & Cons


  • More than 50 years in the industry 
  • Customizable plans
  • Premium coverage with high coverage limits
  • Payment plan choices


  • Pricing tends to be a bit higher than some other providers

Plans and Pricing 

PlanPrice Per MonthPrice Per Year
ShieldSilver Systems Plan$39.99$479.88
ShieldGold Combo Plan $49.99$599.88
ShieldPlatinum Combo Plan$64.99$779.88


As we mentioned with Choice Home Warranty, the cover caps are an essential consideration for first-time home buyers. With American Home Shield, you will still get that same premium coverage of more than 2,500 dollars worth of coverage for any covered item. American Home Shield is known for paying out a high number of Home Warranty claims each year. If you follow the regulations set forth in your home warranty policy,  you will have no issues with American Home Shield following through on repairs and replacements.

First-time homebuyers who are nervous about caring for and maintaining a home should seriously consider the American Home Shield Home Warranty. Even though the pricing of the AHS plans is slightly higher, In the end, the value is there.

To get a free quote from American Home Shield, you can fill out this form or call 888-365-2839. 

To read more, visit our American Home Shield review.

3. Select Home Warranty

Most Cost-Effective
Select Home Warranty
  • 3 plans ranging from $52-$58 per month + optional add-ons
  • Provides free roof leak coverage
  • Covers rental properties, mobile homes, manufactured homes, single-family homes, and condos
  • Affordable service fee of $60

Select Home Warranty is a very reasonably priced choice for first-time home buyers. Many times when purchasing a home, you will spend more money than you thought you would. If you find yourself on a tight budget, the Select Home Warranty is an excellent policy to consider for your home. With Select Home Warranty, you will find and that you get excellent coverage and a very fair cost. Each select home warranty policy also comes with free roof leak coverage.

Select Home Warranty has more than nine years in the home warranty industry. One thing that sets select apart from other Home Warranty companies is their strict repair technician qualification process.  Select Home Warranty ensures that you are comfortable with the service repair technician coming to your home. In addition, this technician will be qualified to repair or replace the covered item.  

Pros & Cons


  • Easy to work with 
  • Free roof leak coverage with each plan 
  • Excellent value for the coverage provided 
  • Has more than nine years of experience in the industry


  • Coverage caps are not as high as some other plans
  • It won’t provide complete customization like the AHS plans 

Plans and Pricing

PlanPrice Per MonthPrice Per Year
Gold Care$52.00$579.99
Bronze Care $52.00$579.99
Platinum Care$58.00$649.99


With the pricing of the select home warranty being slightly lower than other companies, you can expect that coverage will be limited in some areas. One of the major limitations of the Select Home Warranty policy is the lower coverage Caps or limits. However, it is still certainly going to be money-saving to have a Select Home Warranty policy in place.

First-time home buyers do not need extra monthly expenses thrown their way in the first few weeks of homeownership. However, an electrical system that needs repair or a washing machine that is beyond repair will certainly impact overall spending and budgeting for first-time home buyers. Select Home Warranty allows this to be avoided.

Select Home Warranty will give you a free quote after filling out this form or calling 888-370-3953.

Read our Select Home Warranty review to learn more.

4. Liberty Home Guard

Most Trustworthy
Liberty Home Guard
  • 3 plans ranging $65-$125 with 25+ optional add-ons
  • Has a 60-day workmanship guarantee on all repairs
  • Customer service available 24 hours a day, seven days a week
  • BBB’s only A+ accredited home warranty provider

Liberty Home Guard is a newer home warranty company available to first-time home buyers. Within the first two years of this policy being on the market, they have managed to earn a BBB rating of an a. When looking at customer reviews and reports about Liberty Home Guard, the customer service and response times continue to come up as positive for this company.

In addition, Liberty Home Guard has some of the most extensive add-on coverages on the market. As a first-time homebuyer, the truth did not want to get involved with fixing sprinklers,  Carpet Cleaning,  locksmith services, and more; the Liberty Home Guard home warranty is a perfect solution.

Pros & Cons


  • Good speed of service
  • It has a 60-day workmanship guarantee
  • A large list of add on coverages
  • 365 days a year of customer help and service


  • Priced a bit higher than other companies
  • Newer home warranty company 

Plans and Pricing

PlanPrice Per MonthPrice Per Year
Appliance Guard$64.99$649.99
Systems Guard$69.99$699.99
Total Home Guard$74.99$749.99


As you have likely noticed, the Liberty Home Guard policies are priced slightly higher than others on the market. However, Liberty Home Guard is available to customers 365 days a year-end; the Total Home Guard package provides comprehensive and extensive coverage of the home. This is one of those situations where you will get what you pay for.

Although the number of years that a home warranty company is spent on the market is an essential indicator of the effectiveness of a plan,  Liberty Home Guard has undoubtedly proved itself as a leader in the industry.

To get a free quote from Liberty Home Guard, fill out this online form or call 866-451-2281. 

To learn more information, visit our Liberty Home Guard review.

5. First American Home Warranty

Best Appliance Coverage
First American Home Warranty
  • 2 plans + optional add-ons
  • Covers improperly installed or maintained items
  • No cap on coverage for HVAC
  • $38–$48.50 per month

First American Home Warranty is a perfect option for first-time homebuyers looking for appliance coverage. Although the comprehensive or combo plans will offer greater peace of mind and more extensive coverage,  they tend to be more expensive. In addition, some first-time homebuyers are not concerned about their systems the way they are worried about their appliances. Although First American Home Warranty offers several different types of policies, the appliance plan is one of the best on the market.

 First American Home Warranty has been around for more than 40 years. In this time, they have narrowed their home warranty coverage options to help make it easier for first-time homebuyers to choose an effective and affordable home warranty plan.  First American Home Warranty has excellent customer service and impressive speed. 

Pros & Cons


  • Excellent appliance coverage for new construction homes
  • Fair pricing 
  • Some systems with no coverage caps
  • Option for 24/7 service calls


  • The contract can be a bit confusing with lots of technical terms 

Plans and Pricing

PlanPrice Per MonthPrice Per Year
Basic Plan $38$456
Premier Plan $48.50$582


The First American Home Warranty is an affordable policy with solid coverage. The Premier Plan offers good all-around coverage, but it will not be as extensive as the coverage offered by Liberty Home Guard or Choice Home Warranty. However, first-time homebuyers interested in saving money and still having adequate coverage will enjoy what this plan has to offer. 

With more than 40 years in the industry, first-time home buyers have learned to trust and rely on the First American Home Warranty company.

To get a free quote from First American Home Warranty, you can fill out this online form or call 833-204-7164. 

To find out more, read our First American Home Warranty review.

6. ServicePlus Home Warranty

Best for Immediate Service
ServicePlus Home Warranty
  • Offers 2 plans + optional add-ons
  • Provides a 24/7 claims hotline open 365 days a year
  • Has a 90-day parts guarantee
  • Allows customers to make unlimited service calls

ServicePlus Home Warranty is an excellent home warranty company when it comes to the speed of repairs. When your HVAC system goes down or you have a plumbing stoppage, the ServicePlus Home Warranty will cover it in a very fast period of time. Many of the claims are handled in less than 24 hours. 

ServicePlus home warranty has been on the market for about five years. They have established a strong reputation as a quick and easy to work with home warranty company. The only issue with the ServicePlus home warranty is that they are not accredited with the BBB. Luckily there are plenty of reviews and reports about the SErvicePlus company on the market; you should be able to find the information you need. 

Pros & Cons


  • Very easy to place a claim 
  • Fair pricing
  • Combo plan with systems and appliances is a good value 
  • Unlimited service calls 


  • Not BBB accredited

Plans and Pricing

PlanPrice Per MonthPrice Per Year
Gold Plan $38$456
Platinum Plan $48.50$582


For first-time homebuyers, they’re nervous about the situations they will run into during their first year of homeownership; the ServicePlus home warranty has excellent coverage. However, the Choice Home Warranty would be a better option for more extensive coverage, increased add-on options, and higher coverage limits.

ServicePlus Home Warranty we’ll handle the issues the first-time home buyers run into in a very short period of time. This helps first-time home buyers to have more peace of mind about their homeownership journey.

To get a free quote from ServicePlus Home Warranty, you can fill out this online form or call 478-210-5091. 

What To Look For When Choosing a Home Warranty For First Time Buyers

Although we narrowed down the best first-time home buyers’ policies to the top six,  you will still need to choose one that is a fit for your home. There are several ways to compare and contrast these home warranty policies. Here are some of the most important things to look for when choosing a home warranty for first-time home buyers.

Plans and Coverage

Comparing a combo plan from American Home Shield to one from Choice Home Warranty or First American Home Warranty will show you the way that the covered items differ from one policy to the next. You cannot assume that a platinum plan from one company will match the Platinum plan from another. It is important for first-time homebuyers to pick and choose the coverages that are the most important to them and find a policy that matches this most closely.

Price and service fees

The price of a first-time home buyer’s warranty must take into consideration the monthly fees as well as the service fees. The more money a plan costs, the more coverage that it will offer. When adding additional options like swimming pools and spas, expect the policy to increase in price at a rather fast pace. The good news for first-time homebuyers is that there are plenty of affordable home warranty options on the market.

Replacement Options

In addition to offering coverage for repairs around your first home, Most home warranty companies also provide replacement coverage. This means if a covered item is not repairable, you will receive money towards a replacement. Replacement coverage will depend on the policy limits as well as the age and condition of your current appliance or system.

Pre-existing Conditions

 Home warranty companies do not protect against pre-existing conditions. However, this is not a problem for most first-time home buyers. Typically when a home is transferred from one homeowner to the next day, the home is in perfect working condition. You can use your inspection from the closing of your home to show a Home Warranty company that there are no pre-existing conditions. This will help for future claims and issues that may come up.


 Home warranty companies are offered across all 50 states. However, each of the companies on our list of the top six best home warranties for first-time homebuyers has different availability. For the most part, if a plant is offered in your state, it will be provided in your town. In addition, the pricing throughout the state and the country should be relatively the same.

Get a Free Quote

from our #1 recommended provider for first-time home buyers

Do First-Time Buyers Need A Home Warranty?

First-time home buyers need to seriously consider putting a home warranty in place for their first year of homeownership. It is very difficult to predict how much it will cost you to keep your home up and running throughout the course of a year. One year you may experience no issues with specific systems or appliances in the home. The next year you could find yourself replacing half of your kitchen.

The unpredictability of homeownership is something that can cause many first-time buyers to get into a poor financial situation. With the way that a home warranty Works, budgeting becomes much easier. Knowing that for a small monthly fee, you are getting hundreds if not thousands of dollars worth of coverage on your appliances and systems will help ease the stress of homeownership.

First-time home buyers on a budget will find plenty of fairly priced policy options among our top six best home warranty companies for first-time home buyers. Don’t let your tight monthly budget stop you from protecting your systems and appliances.

Many first-time homebuyers have no idea how expensive it is to have something like an electrical system or Plumbing stoppage repair. If you are curious as to whether or not a first-time home buyer’s warranty is worth money, take a look at some of the repair costs that could be coming your way.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should a seller provide a home warranty?

Some first-time homebuyers are lucky in that a seller will provide a home warranty for the first year. This is an excellent benefit for first-time homebuyers who need to consider renewing this policy before its expiration. Letting the coverage Labs could result in another 30-day wait. Prior to the policy starting.

What is a service fee?

 A service fee is a price you pay each time you need a repair or replacement of a covered item. Service fees range in price from around $60 to $150. Overall, service fees are lower than the price it would cost to have a repair technician come to your home and diagnose an issue. Some home warranty companies refer to the service fee as a deductible.

What does a first-time buyer’s home warranty cover?

 The first-time home buyers warranty will cover expenses related to repairing and replacement of systems and appliances in the home. Not all systems and appliances will be covered, and not all issues related to the systems and appliances will be covered. Home warranty policies are designed to protect against normal wear and not intentional breakage or misuse.

Do first-time buyers need both appliance and system coverage?

Furnace home warranty coverage is well worth the price. Since furnaces are expensive and require certified repair technicians to work with them, the overall value you get with a home warranty plan is quite good. Not all appliances and systems have the same need for a warranty the way that the furnace does.

What does a first-time home buyers warranty cost?

First-time home buyers can expect to pay anywhere from around $38 a month to over $75 a month. The pricing is impacted by the number of covered items,  the service fees, and the overall policy benefits. As a first-time homebuyer, it can make sense to purchase a more affordable plan and then upgrade to a Premium plan after you see the benefits of having a home warranty in place.

Final Thoughts

We hope you now feel you can choose a first-time home buyer’s warranty for your home. Owning a home is an impressive accomplishment,  however, it can also be very stressful. To start enjoying all homeownership instead of worrying about it, the Choice Home Warranty is a perfect option for first-time homebuyers. It is essential to consider getting a few quotes for your first-time home buyers warranty. Sometimes there are sign-up incentives or unique coverage benefits to an individual plan in your state. Getting two or three quotes will help ensure that you get the best value for your home warranty.

See the Best Home Warranty Companies in Your State

House Method Home Warranty Ranking Methodology

At House Method, transparency and trust are our most important values for the reader. That’s why we took the time to create an objective rating system and score each home warranty provider according to our methodology.

We’ve done the homework for you and have researched over 50 home warranty companies so you can have the information you need to make the best choice for your home. Additionally, transparency and trust are our most important values for the reader.

That’s why we took the time to create an objective rating system and score each home warranty provider according to our methodology. Our team spent hours on the phone speaking to representatives from each home warranty company to get information right from the source. We also dug into the fine print on each company’s service agreement to make sure no detail was left out.

To make the most of our research, we developed a formula to objectively determine the best home warranty companies based on the following criteria:

  • Plans: Do they provide a variety of plan options? We looked at the number of plans each company offered and the flexibility of adjusting the plan.
  • Prices: How reasonable are the monthly fees and service fees in comparison to the industry average? We compared the costs of each company to competitors.
  • Coverage: How many items are covered in each plan? We looked at the number of items each company covers. We dig into all service contracts available to get all the details.
  • Customer service: How is the customer experience when calling the providers? Based on our phone calls, we were able to judge each company’s customer service.
  • Trust: What do customers rate the company? We looked into what customers are saying about their experience with the company.
  • Nationwide availability: How many states does the company cover? We found the number of states covered by each company.
  • Unique perks: Does the company offer discounts or cover special items? We looked for perks offered by each company that sets them apart from the competition.

How do we keep our data up to date?

We want to make sure we’re providing you, the consumer, with the most current data available for every home warranty company we’ve researched and rated. That takes significant effort but we feel that’s vital to providing you thorough and trustworthy reviews.

With that in mind, we have dedicated staff members who regularly update our database of home warranty research.

For those that want to  come home to a house that is comfortable and functioning, a home warranty makes a lot of sense. For the price that a home warranty is offered, you will quickly learn that it is indeed a good value. At an average of around $40 per month, your policy will cost you just under $500 per year.

If you have ever had an appliance or a home system that needs repair, you probably understand quite well that you will quickly reach that $500 mark to get your home back up and running. Take your time to carefully consider your home warranty options, check around for discounts and then give yourself the peace of mind that you deserve.

More Home Warranty Resources