When Do Americans Stop Believing in Santa
by State

By David Cusick

If you celebrate Christmas, it’s likely that you believed in Santa Claus at some point in your life. As a child, it’s part of the joy of Christmas as children send off their Christmas wish lists to the North Pole, bake cookies for Santa and his reindeer, and try to listen for him on Christmas Eve. 

Unfortunately, however, it eventually all comes to an end as children realize that Santa isn’t real and he isn’t the one putting the presents under the tree. We all stop believing in Santa Claus at different ages while others never believed at all. At House Method, we usually write about more practical things like the cheapest home warranty or the best home warranty companies, but because we’re in the holiday spirit, we did some research on what age Americans stopped believing in the big man in the big red suit, Santa. 

We surveyed over 4,500 Americans and asked them if they ever believed in Santa and if so, at what age did they stop believing. Keep reading to see what we learned: 

We went ahead and broke down the average age Americans stopped believing in Santa by state. Overall, the average age in the United States for no longer believing in Santa Claus is 8.4 years old. 

Mississippi has the oldest average age at 10.2 years old. Not far behind is Iowa where the average age is 9.9 years old. Rounding out the top five oldest are Montana (9.8), Hawaii (9.5), and Delaware and Washington, D.C. are tied at 9.4 years old.

At the other end are states like Oregon and Arkansas where kids stopped believing a little earlier in life. People of Oregon stopped believing at 7.4 years old, the youngest in the nation, and in Arkansas at 7.6 years old. Nevada (7.7), Oklahoma and Wisconsin (7.8 each), and Alabama and South Dakota (7.9 each) round out the top five.

If 10 seems too old to stop believing in Santa and seven seems too young, just remember there are people who never believed in Santa at all.

Read more: The Most Popular Christmas Movie in Each State

New Mexico and Vermont have a lot of non-believers. Both states had 10% of respondents say that they never believed in Santa at all. But on the flip side, Maine, Tennessee, Utah, and Wyoming have enough Santa spirit to spread across the entire country with 0% of respondents in those states say they never believed in Santa. That means everyone who took the survey in those states believed in Santa at one point or another. 

Read more: American Home Shield review

Below is a table with the information from both of the map graphics.

When Do Americans Stop Believing in Santa by State

State

Average Age

% Who Never Believed

Alabama

7.9

3.0%

Alaska

8.5

5.6%

Arizona

8.3

2.8%

Arkansas

7.6

6.9%

California

8.1

7.0%

Colorado

8.2

1.5%

Connecticut

8.5

1.4%

Delaware

9.4

4.5%

District of Columbia

9.4

2.6%

Florida

8.7

2.6%

Georgia

8.4

5.8%

Hawaii

9.5

5.0%

Idaho

8.7

3.3%

Illinois

8.5

3.8%

Indiana

8.4

9.5%

Iowa

9.9

9.8%

Kansas

8.5

2.8%

Kentucky

8.3

3.2%

Louisiana

8.6

3.8%

Maine

8.1

0%

Maryland

8.4

8.3%

Massachusetts

8.3

2.9%

Michigan

8.3

2.6%

Minnesota

9

6.0%

Mississippi

10.2

8.3%

Missouri

8.3

3.9%

Montana

9.8

6.7%

Nebraska

8.6

3.6%

Nevada

7.7

5.9%

New Hampshire

9.1

2.9%

New Jersey

8.1

5.1%

New Mexico

8.7

10.0%

New York

8.3

3.3%

North Carolina

8.6

3.8%

North Dakota

8.6

3.4%

Ohio

8.2

2.2%

Oklahoma

7.8

4.9%

Oregon

7.4

4.1%

Pennsylvania

8.3

1.6%

Rhode Island

8.8

3.7%

South Carolina

8.8

5.0%

South Dakota

7.9

7.7%

Tennessee

8.2

0%

Texas

8.8

4.6%

Utah

8

0%

Vermont

8

10.0%

Virginia

8.5

0.7%

Washington

8.1

4.5%

West Virginia

8.5

0%

Wisconsin

7.8

1.2%

Wyoming

8.9

0%

And before you go, let’s talk about how much better it to enjoy Christmas than it is doing work around your house. That’s something we can all agree on. With that in mind, let’s talk about home warranties. A home warranty can protect you from costly repairs from systems and appliances breakdowns. So if you’re looking for some help with home repairs and maybe save a little money at the same time, consider a home warranty. Check out our in-depth reviews to see which one may be right for you — all of them offer free quotes! 

Methodology

We surveyed 4,580 Americans in mid-November, 2019, asking them when they stopped believing in Santa Claus. The survey respondents were not limited to specific demographics. We estimate the margin of error at 1%. 

Home Warranty

Ask a Pool Expert: How Much Does it Cost to Maintain a Pool?

Pool ownership can be a significant investment of time and money. Read what a pool expert had to say about the reality of at-home pool maintenance and cost.

Home insurance concept. Businessman hold umbrella, modern cottage and paper agreement. Warranty and shield symbol. Protection concept background. Trendy style vector illustration
Home Warranty

Home Warranty Glossary

Browse our glossary of home warranty terms so you can better understand how your policy protects the major appliances and systems throughout your home.

Real estate agent selling a home
Home Warranty

Ask a Real Estate Agent: Are Home Warranties Worth it?

House Method sat down with Brandelyn Jones, a real estate agent with Realty One Group in Goodyear, Arizona, for her expert take on how home warranties can be a valuable asset for homebuyers and sellers. Residing in Arizona since 1997, Brandelyn has specific expertise in the Phoenix Metropolitan market and other neighboring communities. 

Home Warranty

10 Household Items a Home Warranty Covers and 5 It Doesn’t

Home warranties cover normal wear and tear on home systems and appliances. To help you understand repair coverage before purchasing a plan, we’ve compiled a list of 10 household items a home warranty covers and five it doesn’t.

Home Warranty

Ask an Electrician: Are Home Warranties Worth it?

House Method reached out to electrical expert Michael Allred of Allred Electrical Services, Inc. for his professional insight into the true value of home warranty coverage for common household electrical failures. Allred draws from his first-hand experience offering premier electrical services to homeowners in North and South Carolina since 1999.

Home Warranty

How COVID-19 Has Increased the Cost of Homeownership

The COVID-19 pandemic triggered an increase in housing prices and a plummet in available properties. Read this guide to understand the impact of COVID-19 on the U.S. real estate market and how other economic drivers propelled inflation forward since 2020.

Home Warranty

The ROI of a Bathroom Remodel in Every State

House Method ran a survey to find out how much homeowners can expect to get back on bathroom remodeling projects. Explore our survey results and more in this study on the ROI of a bathroom remodel in every state.

Home Warranty

Why Now Is the Time To Invest in a Home Warranty

Now is the time to act if you’ve considered purchasing a home service contract. We’ll explain why you should invest in a home warranty for crucial coverage of your home’s systems and appliances.

Home Warranty

How to File a Home Warranty Claim

There are several steps in the home warranty claims process, some of which can make or break your plan’s success. We’ll show you the four steps to filing a successful claim with your home warranty provider.